UPDATE: Court-ordered release of Slidell emails reveals halted vehicle purchases amid ethics concerns

Judge orders disclosure of emails previously withheld under attorney-client privilege; records raise questions about sheriff candidate Daniel Seuzeneau’s outside employment with Matt Bowers businesses

SLIDELL — Internal City of Slidell emails that officials had withheld from a public records request under a claim of attorney-client privilege were ordered released Friday by a district judge following a private review of the correspondence, revealing that the city’s finance director had placed proposed vehicle purchases from Matt Bowers businesses on hold amid apparent ethics concerns involving sheriff candidate Daniel Seuzeneau’s outside employment.

The disclosure came after 22nd Judicial District Judge Martin E. Coady reviewed the disputed emails in camera — outside public view — and ordered the city to produce them after declining to uphold its privilege claim for the released correspondence.

The emails reveal that city officials were examining potential ethics concerns involving transactions with Matt Bowers businesses in late 2025. Seuzeneau, a former Slidell police official now running for St. Tammany Parish sheriff, had an outside employment relationship involving those businesses.

In a Dec. 17, 2025, email, Finance Director Blair Ellinwood told City Attorney Thomas Schneidau she was holding proposed vehicle purchases from Matt Bowers while questioning whether the police department should continue using those businesses for vehicle repairs.

Court-ordered emails: A Dec. 17, 2025, email from Slidell Finance Director Blair Ellinwood (left) reveals that she was holding proposed vehicle purchases from Matt Bowers businesses while questioning continued police vehicle repairs. The emails were released Friday following a judge’s review of the city’s attorney-client privilege claim. (Mandeville Daily)
Court-ordered emails: A Dec. 17, 2025, email from Slidell Finance Director Blair Ellinwood (left) reveals that she was holding proposed vehicle purchases from Matt Bowers businesses while questioning continued police vehicle repairs. The emails were released Friday following a judge’s review of the city’s attorney-client privilege claim. (Mandeville Daily)

However, no purchase orders or other documentation substantiating the proposed vehicle acquisitions referenced in Ellinwood’s email were identified among the records produced by the city in response to two public records requests. Attorney Ross F. Lagarde, who represents the plaintiff in the resulting litigation, confirmed Saturday that no such records were included in the city’s production.

Ellinwood also identified “Daniel” as the official signing off on the repair purchase orders, an apparent reference to Seuzeneau.

An earlier email exchange carried the subject line “42:1112,” an apparent reference to Louisiana’s governmental ethics law restricting public servants’ participation in certain transactions involving personal financial interests.

The correspondence does not establish that Seuzeneau violated the law or that his outside employment was definitively the reason the purchases were halted. However, it raises questions about the city’s handling of potential conflicts involving businesses associated with his outside employment.

The emails were released as part of a public records lawsuit filed by Dominick J. Latino III, whose attorney, Lagarde, had challenged the city’s handling of records concerning Seuzeneau and Matt Bowers businesses.

Finance director questioned purchases and repairs

In her Dec. 17 email to Schneidau, titled “purchasing questions,” Ellinwood wrote:

“I’m holding the purchase of vehicles from Matt Bowers however we use them to repairs our police vehicles. Is that something we should be sending somewhere else? The POs are initiated by vehicle maintenance, Ryan, but are signed off by Daniel.”

Ellinwood identified “Daniel” as the official signing off on purchase orders for police vehicle repairs. During Friday’s hearing, City Attorney Thomas Schneidau was questioned about Seuzeneau’s involvement in approving vehicle repairs. Schneidau explained that purchase orders were routed through various departments and that an official’s involvement did not necessarily mean that person initiated the transaction.

Those repair transactions are distinct from the proposed vehicle acquisitions Ellinwood said she was holding. No corresponding purchase orders documenting those proposed acquisitions were produced.

Seuzeneau’s outside employment with Matt Bowers businesses, coupled with his apparent role in approving expenditures for repairs performed by those businesses, raises questions about potential conflicts of interest. The correspondence does not establish whether his outside compensation was connected to any particular city transaction.

Earlier correspondence points to ethics concerns

The Dec. 17 email followed an earlier exchange between Ellinwood and Schneidau concerning Matt Bowers and the Slidell Police Department.

On Dec. 11, Ellinwood asked:

“I was just wondering if you heard anything back yet on Matt Bowers for SPD?”

Schneidau responded:

“I never heard from my contact, will try to follow up soon. I do have continuing hesitation on it”

Court-ordered emails: An earlier exchange with City Attorney Thomas Schneidau (right) references Louisiana’s governmental ethics law and his “continuing hesitation” concerning Matt Bowers transactions. The emails were released Friday following a judge’s review of the city’s attorney-client privilege claim. (Mandeville Daily)
Court-ordered emails: An earlier exchange with City Attorney Thomas Schneidau (right) references Louisiana’s governmental ethics law and his “continuing hesitation” concerning Matt Bowers transactions. The emails were released Friday following a judge’s review of the city’s attorney-client privilege claim. (Mandeville Daily)

The exchange carried the subject line “RE: 42:1112.”

Louisiana Revised Statute 42:1112 is part of the state’s Code of Governmental Ethics. It generally restricts public servants from participating in certain governmental transactions involving personal financial interests, including interests held by specified related parties or businesses.

The statutory reference suggests officials were considering the Matt Bowers matter in the context of governmental ethics requirements. However, the correspondence does not identify the precise legal concern or establish whether the city sought a formal ethics opinion.

A Nov. 6, 2025, email header bearing the same statutory reference indicates discussions concerning the issue began at least several weeks before Ellinwood’s Dec. 17 message.

The public records requests also sought ethics advisory opinions concerning the transactions. According to attorneys familiar with the litigation, the city produced none, leaving unanswered whether officials sought formal guidance from the Louisiana Board of Ethics.

Seuzeneau’s outside employment becomes central issue

Seuzeneau’s outside business activities were among the principal subjects of the public records litigation.

During Friday’s hearing, Lagarde questioned police department officials about records documenting Seuzeneau’s authorization to perform outside work.

The city’s records production included only one secondary employment authorization for Seuzeneau, dated 2020 and approved by then-Police Chief Randy Fandal. No subsequent authorizations were produced, leaving no documented approval for his outside employment in later years among the records provided by the city.

According to Lagarde, that authorization identified employment involving a Matt Bowers business rather than Southern Rogue Media, the consulting business associated with Seuzeneau.

The distinction became relevant during questioning about whether an officer operating a consulting business with multiple clients would require authorization for the consulting company itself or for individual employers.

Lagarde also questioned officials about a department policy requiring annual authorization for outside employment.

However, testimony did not conclusively establish which version of the policy governed Seuzeneau’s employment or whether its requirements changed after his 2020 authorization.

Proposed vehicle purchases remain unexplained

During Friday’s hearing, Schneidau acknowledged that city officials had considered purchasing a vehicle from a Matt Bowers-affiliated business.

He testified that attorney-client communications occurred in November and December 2025 concerning whether such a purchase could proceed and that officials ultimately decided against it. However, neither his testimony nor the records produced by the city in response to the two public records requests explain what initially prompted those communications.

Additionally, Schneidau said he had consulted the city’s finance department, fleet maintenance personnel and police department and was confident Slidell had not purchased vehicles directly from Matt Bowers businesses during the period reviewed.

His testimony establishes the city’s position that no purchase was completed, but it does not explain how far the proposed transactions progressed.

Ellinwood’s Dec. 17 email referred to holding the purchase of “vehicles,” plural, while Schneidau testified about a proposed purchase involving a single vehicle.

The descriptions are not necessarily contradictory, but they leave unanswered whether the proposals had advanced beyond preliminary discussions.

Reached for comment Saturday, Lagarde confirmed that the records produced by the city contained no purchase orders or proposed purchase orders documenting the acquisitions. He also said he had no evidence that Seuzeneau signed or approved purchase orders for the proposed vehicle purchases.

The absence of those documents does not establish that formal purchase orders existed or that the city failed to produce records in its possession.

It does, however, leave unresolved who initiated the proposed purchases, whether quotes or requisitions were prepared and what prompted Ellinwood to hold the transactions.

City describes vehicle leasing arrangements

Schneidau also testified that Slidell had leased approximately 30 to 40 vehicles through Enterprise since about 2021.

Under the program, Enterprise acquires vehicles and leases them to the city.

Schneidau said Enterprise provided written confirmation that it had no relationship with Matt Bowers entities under its Slidell contract.

Nothing in the released emails establishes that the proposed Matt Bowers purchases were subsequently completed through Enterprise or another intermediary.

Court awards $2,500 in attorney fees

The emails were among records the city had withheld under a claim of attorney-client privilege.

Following his private review Friday, Coady ordered the correspondence released.

In an email to the attorneys that afternoon, Jack E. “Bobby” Truitt, who represented the city in the lawsuit, wrote:

“Attached are the emails that the Court reviewed in camera and ordered produced.”

The release followed earlier proceedings in which the city maintained that it had produced responsive records. According to Lagarde, the city subsequently produced more than 500 additional pages after an earlier hearing.

During Friday’s proceedings, Coady determined that the writ of mandamus seeking production of records had been satisfied, effectively resolving that portion of the litigation.

However, Coady also ordered the city to pay $2,500 in attorney fees to the plaintiff’s legal counsel, acknowledging concerns about the time and effort required to obtain the requested records.

Questions remain unanswered

The newly released emails leave unanswered what prompted Slidell officials to place proposed vehicle purchases from Matt Bowers businesses on hold, how far those transactions progressed and why no supporting procurement records were included in the city’s responses to two public records requests.

Mandeville Daily contacted Jack E. “Bobby” Truitt, who represented the City of Slidell in the public records lawsuit, by email and text message Saturday afternoon, requesting comment on the newly released correspondence and the absence of supporting procurement records. No response had been received as of publication.

The records also leave unresolved whether the city subsequently changed its vehicle repair arrangements with Matt Bowers businesses or took other steps to address potential conflicts involving Seuzeneau’s outside employment.

-30-


Related Stories:


© 2026 Mandeville Daily. All rights reserved. Republishing permitted with attribution and link to the original article.

"The Prestigious Catahoula Newshound Award. An award I made up, then gave it to myself… five times." — "Wild" Bill Kropog, Editor Emeritus
“The Prestigious Catahoula Newshound Award. An award I made up, then gave it to myself… five times.” — “Wild” Bill Kropog, Editor Emeritus

Judge declares anti-Seuzeneau advertising restraining order moot

Preliminary injunction hearing continued indefinitely after Three Rivers PAC revises television commercial

TV ads continue to run and website remains live

COVINGTON — A St. Tammany Parish judge on Monday declared a temporary restraining order against political advertising targeting sheriff candidate Daniel Seuzeneau moot after Three Rivers PAC revised its television commercial, effectively ending the immediate restrictions at the center of a lawsuit filed just days before Tuesday’s election.

Judge Vincent J. Lobello of the 22nd Judicial District Court signed an order Nov. 2 continuing a scheduled preliminary injunction hearing without setting a new date.

The order also directs the release of a $3,000 cash bond posted by the plaintiff, Gregory P. Johnson II, and acknowledges that a revised version of the disputed television advertisement remains in circulation.

The developments follow a weekend of uncertainty surrounding a temporary restraining order reportedly issued Saturday, questions about whether Three Rivers PAC had received proper notice and conflicting information about a hearing scheduled for Monday morning.

The signed order, electronically filed Monday afternoon, provides the first definitive court documentation resolving several of those questions.

Read the consent order signed Nov. 2 here…

Temporary restraining order declared moot

The court’s order establishes that a temporary restraining order was signed Oct. 31, resolving earlier uncertainty about the authenticity of an apparently signed document circulated on social media over the weekend.

It was Scott C. Gardner, district judge for Division G, who signed the order.

However, the Nov. 2 order does not address whether the Oct. 31 temporary restraining order had been properly served or when or even if it became enforceable against Three Rivers PAC.

An excerpt from the Nov. 2 order signed by 22nd Judicial District Judge Vincent J. Lobello declares the Oct. 31 temporary restraining order against Three Rivers PAC moot following revisions to its television advertisement. The order also continues the preliminary injunction hearing indefinitely and directs the return of a $3,000 cash bond. (St. Tammany Parish Clerk of Court)
An excerpt from the Nov. 2 order signed by 22nd Judicial District Judge Vincent J. Lobello declares the Oct. 31 temporary restraining order against Three Rivers PAC moot following revisions to its television advertisement. The order also continues the preliminary injunction hearing indefinitely and directs the return of a $3,000 cash bond. (St. Tammany Parish Clerk of Court)

Instead, the judge’s ruling focuses on changes to the advertising.

The order states that Three Rivers PAC revised its original television commercial and that the revised advertisement is currently circulating.

As a result, the court declared the Oct. 31 temporary restraining order moot.

The ruling does not determine whether the original advertisement contained false statements or violated Louisiana election law. It also does not establish that the restraining order was invalid when originally issued.

Rather, the court accepted an arrangement reached by the parties following discussions involving their attorneys.

Hearing continued without date

The court also ordered that the preliminary injunction hearing scheduled for Monday be continued without date.

That means no replacement hearing has been scheduled.

A document circulated Saturday by the Facebook page A Better Mandeville had indicated that a hearing would take place at 9 a.m. Monday. However, no public hearing took place at that time.

Monday’s signed order states that the matter came before the court Nov. 2 and identifies attorneys participating either in person or by telephone.

It further indicates that the court acted following a conference with counsel and with the parties’ consent.

The order identifies Brian F. Trainor as counsel for Johnson and Scott L. Sternberg as counsel for Three Rivers PAC.

Both sides approved the order’s form and substance.

PAC’s revised advertising remains in circulation

The judge’s order specifically acknowledges that Three Rivers PAC revised its original television commercial and that the revised advertisement continues to circulate.

The order does not identify the particular changes made to the commercial.

The revision appeared relatively minor, involving the removal of an animated dollar counter, or “ticker,” that displayed a monetary figure substantially higher than the amount at issue, while leaving the remainder of the advertisement largely unchanged.

The dispute arose from advertisements critical of Seuzeneau, including television advertising and material published through the SneakyDaniel.com website.

Johnson’s lawsuit alleges that the advertising falsely portrays Seuzeneau’s outside employment and financial arrangements, including payments associated with a local automobile dealership.

The petition also challenges advertising language suggesting that Seuzeneau was involved in questionable conduct or could bring another scandal to the St. Tammany Parish Sheriff’s Office.

Those assertions remain allegations made by Johnson. The court has not ruled on their truth or falsity.

Lawsuit remains pending

Although the temporary restraining order has been declared moot and the preliminary injunction hearing postponed indefinitely, the lawsuit has not been dismissed.

The order states that Johnson intends to seek another preliminary injunction hearing if the dispute is not resolved or if the original television commercial is broadcast again.

That provision leaves open the possibility of further litigation.

However, with the sheriff’s election scheduled for Tuesday, any future hearing would occur after the immediate pre-election advertising period unless the court takes additional action.

The dispute centers on Louisiana’s election advertising law, which allows certain legal challenges to allegedly false campaign statements.

Johnson filed his emergency petition Friday, Oct. 30, seeking to restrict advertisements distributed by Three Rivers PAC.

News publisher seeks court order restricting political speech

Johnson operates The Rabbit Hole, an online publication that presents itself as a source of news and information.

His involvement in the lawsuit has drawn attention because he is both the plaintiff seeking restrictions on political advertising and the publisher of an outlet covering the sheriff’s election.

Johnson’s attorney, Trainor, also represented Seuzeneau during an Oct. 28 hearing in a separate public records lawsuit involving the Slidell Police Department.

Johnson’s court filings acknowledge that he consulted Seuzeneau about the disputed advertisements.

Those documented connections do not, by themselves, establish that Seuzeneau directed or participated in Johnson’s lawsuit.

Dispute ends without ruling on advertising claims

The Nov. 2 order resolves the immediate controversy over the temporary restraining order without deciding whether Three Rivers PAC’s original advertising was false or unlawful.

The PAC’s revised commercial remains in circulation, the court has released the plaintiff’s bond and no further hearing is currently scheduled.

The case remains open, but the emergency effort to restrict the original advertisements has ended without a judicial determination of the underlying allegations.

The case is Gregory P. Johnson II v. Three Rivers PAC, No. 2026-17046, Division F, 22nd Judicial District Court.

The signed order was electronically filed at 3:34 p.m. Monday and accepted by the clerk’s office at 3:50 p.m.

-30-


© 2026 Mandeville Daily. All rights reserved. Republishing permitted with attribution and link to the original article.

"The Prestigious Catahoula Newshound Award. An award I made up, then gave it to myself… five times." — "Wild" Bill Kropog, Editor Emeritus
“The Prestigious Catahoula Newshound Award. An award I made up, then gave it to myself… five times.” — “Wild” Bill Kropog, Editor Emeritus

Lawsuit seeks to block Three Rivers PAC ads targeting sheriff candidate Seuzeneau

Purported injunction circulates online, but court filing and enforcement status remain unconfirmed; advertisements continue airing

COVINGTON — A lawsuit filed Friday in the 22nd Judicial District Court seeks to restrict political advertisements targeting St. Tammany Parish sheriff candidate Daniel Seuzeneau, but questions remain about whether a temporary restraining order reportedly signed Saturday has been formally issued or taken effect.

Meanwhile, the advertisements at the center of the dispute continued appearing on television Saturday evening, and the website hosting the challenged material remained operational as of publication.

Court records confirm that Gregory P. Johnson II filed an injunction lawsuit Oct. 30 against Three Rivers Political Action Committee.

However, as of publication time Saturday, no documents associated with the lawsuit, including the petition or any signed orders, were available through the St. Tammany Parish Clerk of Court’s publicly accessible online records system.

Screenshot from SneakyDaniel.com, a website funded by Three Rivers PAC, features advertisements targeting St. Tammany Parish sheriff candidate Daniel Seuzeneau. The website alleges a connection between Seuzeneau’s outside employment with an automobile dealership and increased payments from the city of Slidell to that dealership. Those allegations are disputed and are at the center of a lawsuit seeking to restrict the advertisements. (SneakyDaniel.com)
Screenshot from SneakyDaniel.com, a website funded by Three Rivers PAC, features advertisements targeting St. Tammany Parish sheriff candidate Daniel Seuzeneau. The website alleges a connection between Seuzeneau’s outside employment with an automobile dealership and increased payments from the city of Slidell to that dealership. Those allegations are disputed and are at the center of a lawsuit seeking to restrict the advertisements. (SneakyDaniel.com)

The case, No. 202617046, is assigned to Division F. Court records identify attorney Brian F. Trainor as representing Johnson.

Plaintiff and Seuzeneau share attorney

Trainor also represented Seuzeneau during Wednesday’s hearing in a separate public records lawsuit filed against the Slidell Police Department by attorney Dominick J. Latino III.

That proceeding resulted in an agreement between attorneys to dismiss Seuzeneau as a defendant after it was established that he was not the department’s designated custodian of public records.

The available records do not establish that Seuzeneau or his campaign is a party to Johnson’s newly filed injunction lawsuit, only that they are both represented by the same attorney.

News publisher seeks court order restricting political speech

Johnson’s involvement in the controversy extends beyond his role as plaintiff.

In Friday’s report, Johnson included an editor’s disclosure acknowledging that he operates The Rabbit Hole, an online publication presenting itself as a source of news and information, and filed the petition challenging the advertisements. Johnson said he believes voters are being misled and that the disputed claims warrant judicial review.

The lawsuit presents an unusual intersection of journalism and political advocacy.

While news organizations have historically challenged government efforts to restrict publication, Johnson’s legal action seeks the opposite result — a court order preventing further distribution of political advertisements he contends contain false statements.

Screenshot of a Facebook post by The Rabbit Hole, operated by lawsuit plaintiff Gregory P. Johnson II, includes an editor’s disclosure acknowledging his role in the legal action against Three Rivers PAC. Johnson is seeking a court order restricting political advertisements targeting sheriff candidate Daniel Seuzeneau. (The Rabbit Hole Facebook page)
Screenshot of a Facebook post by The Rabbit Hole, operated by lawsuit plaintiff Gregory P. Johnson II, includes an editor’s disclosure acknowledging his role in the legal action against Three Rivers PAC. Johnson is seeking a court order restricting political advertisements targeting sheriff candidate Daniel Seuzeneau. (The Rabbit Hole Facebook page)

Plaintiff claims judge signed restraining order

In a Saturday report published by The Rabbit Hole, Johnson claimed that a judge signed an order directing the issuance of a temporary restraining order against Three Rivers PAC.

According to Johnson, the order prohibits the PAC from creating, funding or distributing certain political advertisements targeting Seuzeneau, including advertisements associated with the website SneakyDaniel.com.

Johnson also claims the order requires the PAC to instruct broadcasters airing the challenged advertisements to remove them.

In an earlier Facebook post Friday, Johnson described the allegations underlying his lawsuit.

According to that account, the advertisements raise questions about Seuzeneau’s outside employment while serving with the Slidell Police Department, potential conflicts of interest and payments involving an automobile dealership.

Johnson claims the lawsuit includes a sworn affidavit from Slidell Mayor Randy Fandal stating that Fandal personally approved Seuzeneau’s outside employment request April 29, 2020.

Johnson also disputes suggestions that Seuzeneau personally made or authorized substantial payments to the dealership.

Mandeville Daily has not independently examined the petition, affidavit or supporting exhibits.

Purported order circulates without filing information

Although several Facebook pages have reported that a temporary restraining order was issued, Mandeville Daily has been unable to independently confirm that the reported restrictions are legally in effect. That is an important distinction.

A Better Mandeville, a local website covering political and government affairs, published an image Saturday of what appears to be a court order bearing a judge’s signature dated Oct. 31.

The reproduced document directs the issuance of a temporary restraining order prohibiting Three Rivers PAC from distributing advertisements identified in Johnson’s petition, those appearing on SneakyDaniel.com and substantially similar advertisements.

It also directs the PAC to instruct broadcasters to remove the advertisements and schedules a hearing for Nov. 2.

However, the document contains no completed case number, filing stamp or clerk’s certification. The identity of the signing judge is not apparent from the reproduced signature.

The absence of filing information suggests the copy may have been obtained directly from someone involved in the proceedings rather than from an official court record.

As of publication time, Mandeville Daily could find no publicly available documentation establishing that the purported order had been formally filed, served on Three Rivers PAC or otherwise officially communicated to the PAC or its representatives.

The absence of such documentation from publicly accessible records does not establish that those actions did not occur.

PAC advertisements continue airing

Despite reports that a judge ordered the advertisements stopped, Mandeville Daily confirmed Saturday evening that SneakyDaniel.com remained accessible and functioning.

Mandeville Daily also personally observed the television advertisement targeting Seuzeneau air at least twice Saturday evening, most recently approximately 30 minutes before publication time.

The continued appearance of the advertisements does not, by itself, establish that Three Rivers PAC has violated a court order, particularly while the order’s issuance, notice and enforceability remain unconfirmed.

Mandeville Daily contacted Three Rivers PAC seeking an official response to the lawsuit and confirmation of whether the reported temporary restraining order had been issued, received or taken effect.

As of publication time, the PAC had not provided an official response or confirmation.

Monday hearing reportedly scheduled

Johnson reported that a hearing is scheduled for Monday, Nov. 2, at which Three Rivers PAC would be required to show cause why a preliminary injunction should not be issued.

The reproduced order lists the hearing for 9 o’clock but does not specify a.m. or p.m.

Other published accounts have reported the hearing time as 9 a.m.

However, the publicly accessible court record displayed no scheduled hearings or docket events as of publication time Saturday.

The 22nd Judicial District Court’s online case management system confirms that Gregory Johnson filed an injunction lawsuit against Three Rivers PAC on Oct. 30. As of Saturday evening, the publicly accessible docket listed no hearings or events and provided no documents confirming that a temporary restraining order had been issued or taken effect. (St. Tammany Parish Clerk of Court)
The 22nd Judicial District Court’s online case management system confirms that Gregory Johnson filed an injunction lawsuit against Three Rivers PAC on Oct. 30. As of Saturday evening, the publicly accessible docket listed no hearings or events and provided no documents confirming that a temporary restraining order had been issued or taken effect. (St. Tammany Parish Clerk of Court)

Mandeville Daily has not independently confirmed the hearing’s time or whether it has been entered on the court’s official calendar.

Political speech protections at issue

The lawsuit raises questions about the circumstances under which courts may restrict political advertising, particularly in the final days before an election.

Political speech receives substantial protection under the First Amendment, and judicial orders restricting speech before publication or distribution can raise constitutional concerns involving prior restraint.

Louisiana law also addresses certain false statements made about candidates during election campaigns.

Whether the challenged advertisements violate those provisions, and whether restrictions on their distribution would satisfy constitutional requirements, are separate legal questions.

The filing of an injunction lawsuit does not establish that the advertisements contain false statements. Likewise, a temporary restraining order, if issued, would not constitute a final determination of the underlying allegations.

With the sheriff’s election scheduled for Tuesday, the reported court proceedings would take place during the campaign’s final hours.

CCST amplifies reports about injunction

Concerned Citizens of St. Tammany (CCST), a Facebook-based organization that has publicly defended Seuzeneau, also shared The Rabbit Hole’s Saturday report claiming that a judge signed a temporary restraining order against Three Rivers PAC.

Concerned Citizens of St. Tammany (CCST) shared sheriff candidate Daniel Seuzeneau’s video announcing his removal from a public records lawsuit, criticizing an unnamed rival campaign it suggested was responsible for the litigation. The Facebook page has publicly defended Seuzeneau and shared reporting favorable to his candidacy. (Facebook)
Concerned Citizens of St. Tammany (CCST) shared sheriff candidate Daniel Seuzeneau’s video announcing his removal from a public records lawsuit, criticizing an unnamed rival campaign it suggested was responsible for the litigation. The Facebook page has publicly defended Seuzeneau and shared reporting favorable to his candidacy. (Facebook)

The organization previously shared Seuzeneau’s public response to the separate Slidell Police Department records lawsuit, sharply criticizing those it believed were responsible for that litigation.

CCST’s subsequent sharing of The Rabbit Hole’s injunction report further circulated Johnson’s claims about the court action.

The social media activity does not, by itself, establish any formal coordination between CCST, Johnson or Seuzeneau’s campaign.

Campaign finance disclosures draw social media attention

Meanwhile, supporters of sheriff candidate Daniel Seuzeneau have circulated Louisiana campaign finance disclosures identifying Robert Hodges as the candidate supported by Three Rivers PAC, the political committee behind the advertisements criticizing Seuzeneau.

The filings show that Three Rivers PAC registered as an independent expenditure-only committee and reported receiving a $45,000 contribution from Common Sense America Election Fund, a Virginia-based political organization, on Oct. 28. According to Federal Election Commission records, Common Sense America Election Fund is a federally registered political committee established in 2022 that has participated in political financing in other states.

Such committees are permitted to raise and spend money independently to support or oppose political candidates, subject to applicable campaign finance and disclosure requirements. This type of fundraising and political advocacy is precisely what PACs are established to conduct, and identifying a candidate as the beneficiary of that activity is not, by itself, evidence of anything improper.

Both the SneakyDaniel.com website and the television advertisements criticizing Seuzeneau carried disclosures identifying Three Rivers PAC as responsible for the advertising. The committee’s involvement was therefore already publicly identified before the campaign finance filings began circulating on social media. The filings provide additional information about the PAC’s financial backing and declared support for Hodges, rather than revealing previously undisclosed responsibility for the advertisements.

The filings do not establish that Hodges directed or coordinated the PAC’s activities, nor do they demonstrate that its advertisements contain false statements or otherwise violate the law. Although the disclosures identify the PAC’s political interests and a substantial contribution, neither document, standing alone, establishes wrongdoing or provides grounds for restricting political speech.

Editor’s note: Mandeville Daily independently confirmed the lawsuit’s filing, parties, assigned judge and plaintiff’s attorney through the 22nd Judicial District Court’s online case management system. The publication also independently confirmed that the challenged website remained operational and observed the television advertisements airing Saturday evening. Although an image of a purported signed order has circulated publicly, the underlying court documents were not available through the clerk’s public online records system at press time, and the order’s filing, service and enforceability could not be independently established.

-30-


© 2026 Mandeville Daily. All rights reserved. Republishing permitted with attribution and link to the original article.

"The Prestigious Catahoula Newshound Award. An award I made up, then gave it to myself… five times." — "Wild" Bill Kropog, Editor Emeritus
“The Prestigious Catahoula Newshound Award. An award I made up, then gave it to myself… five times.” — “Wild” Bill Kropog, Editor Emeritus

Sheriff candidate Seuzeneau to be removed from Slidell public records lawsuit

Court schedules Nov. 13 hearing as questions remain over completeness of records production

COVINGTON — St. Tammany Parish sheriff candidate Daniel Seuzeneau will be removed as a defendant in a public records lawsuit against the Slidell Police Department following a hearing Wednesday in the 22nd Judicial District Court.

Attorneys for both sides agreed to dismiss Seuzeneau after establishing that he was not the department’s designated custodian of public records. The parties agreed to submit the necessary paperwork formalizing his dismissal.

Seuzeneau’s inclusion in the lawsuit stemmed in part from information on the Slidell Police Department’s website identifying his administrative role, along with department records showing that although he resigned as chief administrative officer July 21 to run for sheriff, he was appointed that same day to an unpaid volunteer position as administrative reserve — special assistant to the chief.

Documents filed in the public records lawsuit show Daniel Seuzeneau’s July 21 resignation letter from his position as chief administrative officer of the Slidell Police Department, left, and a personnel order signed the same day by Police Chief Tommy Williams appointing Seuzeneau as Administrative Reserve — Special Assistant to the Chief for an indefinite period, right. (Mandeville Daily excerpts from Slidell Police Department public records.)
Documents filed in the public records lawsuit show Daniel Seuzeneau’s July 21 resignation letter from his position as chief administrative officer of the Slidell Police Department, left, and a personnel order signed the same day by Police Chief Tommy Williams appointing Seuzeneau as Administrative Reserve — Special Assistant to the Chief for an indefinite period, right. (Mandeville Daily excerpts from Slidell Police Department public records.)

The lawsuit, filed Sept. 30 by attorney Dominick J. Latino III, alleges that the Slidell Police Department failed to comply with Louisiana’s Public Records Law following a request for extensive departmental records, including personnel files, disciplinary records and information concerning Seuzeneau’s outside employment. A subsequent records request, also discussed during Wednesday’s hearing, sought information about the city’s vehicle leasing arrangements with Enterprise and communications involving local businessman Matt Bowers and his automobile dealerships.

Mandeville Daily illustration depicting the St. Tammany Parish sheriff’s election and an ongoing public records lawsuit against the Slidell Police Department. Sheriff candidate Daniel Seuzeneau is being removed as a defendant, but the underlying lawsuit continues, with another court hearing scheduled for Nov. 13. (Mandeville Daily)
Mandeville Daily illustration depicting the St. Tammany Parish sheriff’s election and an ongoing public records lawsuit against the Slidell Police Department. Sheriff candidate Daniel Seuzeneau is being removed as a defendant, but the underlying lawsuit continues, with another court hearing scheduled for Nov. 13. (Mandeville Daily)

During Wednesday’s hearing, attorneys identified Capt. Richard Bowman as the department’s designated records custodian, prompting an agreement to amend the lawsuit to identify the appropriate officials.

Slidell City Attorney Thomas Schneidau, police Capt. Richard Bowman and Sgt. Josh Funck testified about the handling of the records requests and documents produced so far. Their testimony indicated that hundreds of documents had been provided, but officials could not yet certify that the responses were complete.

Judge Martin E. Coady directed the city and police department to address the outstanding certification requirements and scheduled another hearing for Friday, Nov. 13, at 10 a.m.

Seuzeneau’s dismissal does not resolve the underlying dispute over whether the city and police department have complied with Louisiana’s Public Records Law.

The proceedings come less than a week before the Nov. 3 primary election for St. Tammany Parish sheriff, in which Seuzeneau is one of four candidates. A runoff election, if necessary, is scheduled for Dec. 12.

-30-


Related Stories:


© 2026 Mandeville Daily. All rights reserved. Republishing permitted with attribution and link to the original article.

"The Prestigious Catahoula Newshound Award. An award I made up, then gave it to myself… five times." — "Wild" Bill Kropog, Editor Emeritus
“The Prestigious Catahoula Newshound Award. An award I made up, then gave it to myself… five times.” — “Wild” Bill Kropog, Editor Emeritus

Slidell public records hearing remains on schedule as questions persist over Seuzeneau’s SPD role

Defense withdraws request to postpone Wednesday’s hearing

Cites Seuzeneau’s resignation without addressing subsequent volunteer appointment

COVINGTON — A hearing in a public records lawsuit against the Slidell Police Department remains scheduled for Wednesday, Oct. 28, after attorneys for the department withdrew a request to postpone the proceedings.

The hearing is set for 9:30 a.m. before Judge Martin E. Coady in Division E of the 22nd Judicial District Court.

The lawsuit, filed Sept. 30 by attorney Dominick J. Latino III, alleges that SPD failed to comply with Louisiana’s Public Records Law following a request for extensive departmental records, including personnel and employment information involving St. Tammany Parish sheriff candidate Daniel Seuzeneau.

The defendants, including SPD, Seuzeneau and two police officers, filed several procedural objections last week, challenging the structure of Latino’s lawsuit and seeking dismissal of the claims against the three individuals.

In an Oct. 22 motion, defense attorney Jack E. Truitt requested that Wednesday’s hearing be postponed because of a scheduling conflict with another trial. Truitt stated in the motion that Latino’s attorney, Ross Lagarde, opposed the request.

However, in a letter filed Monday, Truitt informed the court that the conflicting trial had been continued and withdrew his request to reschedule the hearing.

Court records Tuesday morning continued to list Wednesday’s hearing at 9:30 a.m. The previously scheduled Nov. 4 hearing was marked canceled.

Seuzeneau’s volunteer appointment remains unaddressed

In a 10-page memorandum filed Oct. 21, the defendants’ attorneys argue that Seuzeneau cannot be compelled to produce departmental records because he resigned from SPD in July and no longer has access to its records or authority over their release.

However, as previously reported by Mandeville Daily, SPD personnel records show that Seuzeneau was appointed to another position July 21, the same day he resigned as chief administrative officer.

The personnel order, signed by Police Chief Tommy Williams, appointed Seuzeneau as Administrative Reserve — Special Assistant to the Chief for an indefinite period.

Documents filed in the public records lawsuit show Daniel Seuzeneau’s July 21 resignation letter from his position as chief administrative officer of the Slidell Police Department, left, and a personnel order signed the same day by Police Chief Tommy Williams appointing Seuzeneau as Administrative Reserve — Special Assistant to the Chief for an indefinite period, right. (Mandeville Daily excerpts from Slidell Police Department public records.)
Documents filed in the public records lawsuit show Daniel Seuzeneau’s July 21 resignation letter from his position as chief administrative officer of the Slidell Police Department, left, and a personnel order signed the same day by Police Chief Tommy Williams appointing Seuzeneau as Administrative Reserve — Special Assistant to the Chief for an indefinite period, right. (Mandeville Daily excerpts from Slidell Police Department public records.)

Louisiana’s civil service rules prohibit classified employees from participating in political campaigns, including running for public office. The restrictions are intended to preserve political neutrality in government employment, protecting public agencies from partisan influence and ensuring that public employees are not subjected to political pressure.

Seuzeneau’s chief administrative officer position was classified, making his resignation necessary to pursue his candidacy. However, his immediate appointment to an unpaid volunteer position raises a separate question: Whether the position involved similar or overlapping departmental duties and, if so, whether those responsibilities would leave him subject to the same political activity restrictions, regardless of compensation.

The defendants’ latest filings do not acknowledge that appointment or explain whether Seuzeneau’s continuing association with SPD involved access to departmental records or authority over their release.

Although the appointment does not necessarily establish that Seuzeneau was a legally designated custodian of public records, the extent of his responsibilities following his resignation remains unclear.

The defendants also challenge the identification of the proper records custodian, the combination of different legal proceedings and the scope of Latino’s public records request. They seek dismissal of the claims against Seuzeneau and the two officers.

As of Tuesday morning, court records showed no ruling on the defendants’ objections, and Wednesday’s hearing remained scheduled for 9:30 a.m., six days before the Nov. 3 sheriff’s election.

-30-


© 2026 Mandeville Daily. All rights reserved. Republishing permitted with attribution and link to the original article.

"The Prestigious Catahoula Newshound Award. An award I made up, then gave it to myself… five times." — "Wild" Bill Kropog, Editor Emeritus
“The Prestigious Catahoula Newshound Award. An award I made up, then gave it to myself… five times.” — “Wild” Bill Kropog, Editor Emeritus

Mandeville audit finds strong finances as sales tax collections continue to climb

Auditor cites strong reserves and no debt as record sales tax collections fuel debate over dedicated funds and upcoming tax renewals

MANDEVILLE — An independent auditor told the Mandeville City Council Thursday that the city maintains exceptionally strong financial reserves and carries no outstanding debt, even as council members debated the continued accumulation of millions of dollars in dedicated sales tax funds.

Michelle Treschwig, CPA, a partner with accounting firm Kushner LaGraize, presented the city’s annual audit for fiscal year 2025, which ended Aug. 31, 2025. The audit received an unmodified, or clean, opinion on the city’s financial statements, although it identified accounting weaknesses and compliance violations.

The audit was submitted approximately six months late and reflects the city’s financial position more than a year ago, rather than its current financial condition.

However, a subsequent report from Finance Director Jessica Farno offered a more recent picture, including record sales tax collections for September 2026, the first month of the city’s current fiscal year.

Together, the presentations highlighted Mandeville’s substantial financial reserves, growing sales tax revenue and questions about how millions of dollars in dedicated funds should be used as several sales taxes approach renewal.

Michelle Treschwig, CPA, a partner at Kushner LaGraize, presents Mandeville’s fiscal year 2025 audit to the City Council on Thursday, Oct. 22, 2026. Finance Director Jessica Farno listens as Treschwig discusses the city’s General Fund reserves and financial position. (Mandeville Daily)
Michelle Treschwig, CPA, a partner at Kushner LaGraize, presents Mandeville’s fiscal year 2025 audit to the City Council on Thursday, Oct. 22, 2026. Finance Director Jessica Farno listens as Treschwig discusses the city’s General Fund reserves and financial position. (Mandeville Daily)

Auditor says Mandeville compares favorably with other governments

Treschwig reported that Mandeville ended FY2025 with approximately $14.6 million in its General Fund, including $14.4 million in unassigned reserves.

That represented approximately 6.6 months of General Fund expenditures, substantially exceeding the Government Finance Officers Association’s recommendation that local governments maintain reserves equivalent to at least two months of regular expenditures.

The council adopted a new reserve policy earlier this year establishing a minimum unassigned General Fund balance of 20% of budgeted operating expenditures, with a target range of 30% to 40%.

Treschwig’s presentation showed that Mandeville’s FY2025 General Fund balance represented approximately 55% of annual expenditures.

Mandeville’s General Fund ended fiscal year 2025 with approximately $14.6 million, substantially exceeding the city’s $10.5 million reserve target and the Government Finance Officers Association’s recommended minimum of $4.4 million. The chart compares actual fund balances with reserve benchmarks for fiscal years 2023-2025. Source: Kushner LaGraize, FY2025 audit presentation. (Kushner LaGraize)
Mandeville’s General Fund ended fiscal year 2025 with approximately $14.6 million, substantially exceeding the city’s $10.5 million reserve target and the Government Finance Officers Association’s recommended minimum of $4.4 million. The chart compares actual fund balances with reserve benchmarks for fiscal years 2023-2025. Source: Kushner LaGraize, FY2025 audit presentation. (Kushner LaGraize)

In dollar terms, the city’s 40% target was approximately $10.5 million, compared with an actual General Fund balance of approximately $14.6 million.

Councilman-at-Large Jason Zuckerman asked Treschwig how Mandeville compared with other municipalities she had audited.

“So far, you’re doing pretty well,” she replied, noting that Mandeville compared favorably even with some parish governments.

Treschwig cited Jefferson Parish, which she said maintains a 15% minimum reserve requirement, and other governments that typically maintain reserves equivalent to two to four months of expenditures.

She also recalled working with a parish government whose General Fund balance had fallen to just $92 before corrective measures were implemented.

Zuckerman pointed out that Mandeville has no outstanding debt, a distinction Treschwig described as significant.

“Yes. That is huge,” she replied.

Asked directly whether she considered the city’s financial position strong, Treschwig answered yes.

However, she emphasized that her assessment applied to FY2025, not the fiscal year that ended Aug. 31, 2026, or the current FY2027 budget year.

The General Fund balance declined approximately $1.2 million during FY2025, from about $15.8 million to $14.6 million. Nevertheless, the remaining reserves substantially exceeded both the city’s new minimum and the professional association’s recommended level.

Council members disagree over growing dedicated funds

Treschwig reported that Mandeville’s governmental funds held approximately $64.7 million in combined balances at the end of FY2025.

That included approximately $26.6 million in the street construction fund, $11.3 million in the District 3 fund and $11.4 million in the special sales tax fund.

Those balances prompted questions about whether dedicated sales taxes are producing more revenue than the city can reasonably spend.

District III Councilwoman Jill Lane expressed reservations about suggestions that the street construction fund contained excessive reserves.

Lane noted that individual street projects can cost $3.5 million to $4 million and questioned whether the fund’s balance would be sufficient to address future infrastructure needs.

Zuckerman countered that the street construction fund had continued growing despite years of spending on resurfacing, striping, maintenance and other improvements.

He said its balance had increased from approximately $18 million in 2019 to about $27 million, a gain of roughly 50%.

“We continue to repave our streets, we do striping maintenance, we do street improvements, and we seem to be spending more, and it seems that it has grown more than 50, 60%,” Zuckerman said.

He questioned whether the continued accumulation of restricted funds should concern officials when the city faces increasing operating expenses.

“We continue to wrestle with increased cost of annual operating expenses, insurance, goods and services, expenses here and there, where we continue to collect and not spend money out of some of these restricted funds,” he said.

The exchange reflected a recurring disagreement over whether the city’s dedicated sales tax revenue is accumulating faster than the city can use it.

Treschwig did not take a position on whether the balances were excessive.

Instead, she suggested examining the city’s planned projects and whether sufficient spending needs exist to justify the accumulated reserves.

“You all do have some healthy balances in here,” she said. “But my question would be do you have the projects to spend the funds on?”

Sales tax collections continue to climb

The city’s sales tax collections have continued increasing since the end of the audited fiscal year.

Treschwig’s presentation showed that Mandeville collected $21.93 million in sales taxes during FY2025, an increase of approximately $360,000, or 1.7%, over FY2024.

Preliminary figures Farno presented at the council’s Sept. 24 meeting showed that collections increased to approximately $23.05 million during FY2026, which ended Aug. 31.

That represented an increase of approximately $1.12 million, or 5.1%, over FY2025.

Mandeville’s annual sales tax collections increased to approximately $23.05 million in fiscal year 2026, up 5.1% from FY2025. Figures for FY2023 through FY2025 are audited; the FY2026 total is preliminary and unaudited. The city’s fiscal year ends Aug. 31. (Mandeville Daily)
Mandeville’s annual sales tax collections increased to approximately $23.05 million in fiscal year 2026, up 5.1% from FY2025. Figures for FY2023 through FY2025 are audited; the FY2026 total is preliminary and unaudited. The city’s fiscal year ends Aug. 31. (Mandeville Daily)

The figures for FY2026 have not yet been audited.

Farno’s latest report showed that the upward trend continued into the current fiscal year.

Mandeville collected approximately $1.95 million in sales and use taxes during September 2026, an increase of approximately $138,000, or 7.6%, over September 2025.

Mandeville collected approximately $1.95 million in sales taxes in September 2026, an increase of $138,000, or 7.6%, over September 2025. Finance Director Jessica Farno said the total was the highest September collection in the city’s history. (Mandeville Daily)
Mandeville collected approximately $1.95 million in sales taxes in September 2026, an increase of $138,000, or 7.6%, over September 2025. Finance Director Jessica Farno said the total was the highest September collection in the city’s history. (Mandeville Daily)

The September total also exceeded the city’s budget projection by approximately $65,000.

Farno said the amount was the highest September sales tax collection in Mandeville’s history.

The September collections are not included in the approximately $23.05 million reported for FY2026 because the city’s new fiscal year began Sept. 1.

The record month followed the Aug. 5 opening of Trader Joe’s in Mandeville, although the city did not provide figures establishing how much of the increase was attributable to the new store.

Farno cautioned that one month of collections was insufficient to establish a trend for the fiscal year.

Nevertheless, she connected the city’s increasing sales tax revenue with the continued accumulation of dedicated fund balances discussed earlier in the meeting.

“Every month, you know, we’re very excited to see that these sales tax revenues are increasing,” Farno said. “That’s driving the increases in the dedicated funds though.”

She suggested that the city should reconsider whether the existing purposes of dedicated sales taxes continue to reflect municipal needs when those taxes come before voters for renewal.

Mandeville voters approved a rededication of sales tax revenue in 2014, shifting one-half cent of an existing 1% sales tax from infrastructure funds to the General Fund. The change initially generated approximately $2.3 million annually for general municipal operations, with collections increasing as taxable sales grew. The rededication helped drive the substantial growth in the city’s General Fund reserves over the following decade, as previously detailed by Mandeville Daily.

Historical General Fund balances show Mandeville’s audited year-end reserve from FY2010 through FY2024. The chart also identifies several significant events—including the 2014 sales tax rededication, the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic, Mayor Clay Madden’s election and Hurricane Ida—for historical context. The event markers do not imply a causal relationship. (Mandeville Daily)
Historical General Fund balances show Mandeville’s audited year-end reserve from FY2010 through FY2024. The chart also identifies several significant events—including the 2014 sales tax rededication, the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic, Mayor Clay Madden’s election and Hurricane Ida—for historical context. The event markers do not imply a causal relationship. (Mandeville Daily)

[View Full-Size Chart ↗]

“Are you servicing the needs of your city with the way the call of the sales tax is written?” Farno asked.

Sales tax renewals could bring difficult decisions

District II Councilman Kevin Vogeltanz raised the approaching expiration of certain dedicated sales taxes during Treschwig’s presentation.

Farno confirmed that renewals are scheduled for 2028 and 2029.

The discussion focused on the city’s dependence on sales tax revenue and the consequences if voters declined to renew taxes that support major municipal programs and capital improvements.

Zuckerman noted that Mandeville collects approximately $22 million annually in sales taxes, compared with about $2.4 million in property taxes.

Farno clarified that the city’s permanent 1% sales tax supporting the General Fund is not subject to renewal.

Other dedicated sales taxes, including those supporting street construction and District 3 projects, require voter approval to continue.

If voters rejected those taxes, Farno said the city would have to scale back capital projects and make cuts affecting the General Fund.

“You would have to radically cut services,” she said.

District I Councilwoman Strong-Thompson cautioned that the discussion involved hypothetical scenarios, but Farno emphasized that residents should understand the potential consequences.

“If you don’t vote for these things, how you see Mandeville today will radically change,” Farno said. “It will have to.”

The discussion also highlighted the distinction between renewing a dedicated tax and reconsidering how its revenue should be allocated.

Both Treschwig and Farno suggested that officials should evaluate the city’s financial needs before deciding whether existing tax dedications should remain unchanged.

Clean audit opinion accompanied by accounting weaknesses

Although Treschwig characterized Mandeville’s financial position favorably, the FY2025 audit identified two material weaknesses in internal financial controls.

One involved procedures for closing the city’s financial records at the end of the fiscal year. The other concerned accounting for capital assets, including infrastructure, land and other city property.

The audit also identified violations involving the Local Government Budget Act, Louisiana’s audit filing requirements and federal reporting deadlines.

Bank reconciliations were not consistently completed within two months after month-end.

The audit was submitted Aug. 28, approximately six months after its Feb. 28 deadline.

Lane noted that the city had submitted audits late in four of the previous five years and questioned whether the capital asset review explained the recurring delays.

Treschwig said she could explain the FY2025 delay but could not account for the circumstances surrounding earlier audits.

For FY2025, she attributed the delay to the capital asset reconciliation project and problems completing the year-end financial closing process.

The capital asset review resulted in a net downward correction of approximately $4.6 million to previously reported financial figures.

Treschwig explained that the city had longstanding problems identifying, classifying and accounting for certain assets, including infrastructure recorded decades earlier.

The adjustment represented a correction of accounting records, not a finding that $4.6 million in city money was missing.

Farno said the city had completed the capital asset review and hired outside accounting assistance to improve financial closing procedures, reconciliations and staff training.

She expressed confidence that the improvements would help resolve the findings in the next audit.

Treschwig emphasized that the FY2025 financial statements nevertheless received an unmodified opinion, meaning they were fairly presented under applicable accounting standards.

Water and sewer operations remain a challenge

The audit also showed that the city’s water and sewer enterprise fund continued operating at a loss, although its results had improved substantially.

The enterprise fund reported an operating loss of approximately $860,000 in FY2025, compared with losses of about $2.9 million in FY2024 and $5.6 million in FY2023.

Farno’s September report showed that the enterprise fund continued facing operating shortfalls in the current fiscal year.

The fund recorded approximately $357,000 in operating revenue and $487,000 in operating expenses during September, producing a shortfall of about $130,000.

The city’s adopted FY2027 budget anticipates an enterprise operating shortfall of approximately $2.26 million.

Farno noted that the first month’s results did not resolve the fund’s ongoing financial challenges.

The September operating expenses included approximately $177,000 in depreciation, a noncash accounting expense.

The city recently increased water and sewer rates, but the FY2025 audit predates the full effect of those changes.

Mayor rejects claims of financial crisis

Madden welcomed Treschwig’s assessment and used the presentation to respond to critics who have questioned the city’s financial condition.

He said Kushner LaGraize was the third auditing firm in three years to describe Mandeville’s finances favorably.

Madden criticized what he called social media “trolls” who have claimed the city is experiencing a financial crisis.

He argued that residents should place greater weight on the findings of independent auditors and other financial professionals.

Vogeltanz agreed that characterizing Mandeville as being in a financial crisis was unwarranted.

However, he said the city’s favorable financial position did not eliminate the need for careful scrutiny of spending, reserves and future obligations.

Next audit already underway

The council unanimously approved a contract with Kushner LaGraize to conduct the FY2026 audit, covering the fiscal year that ended Aug. 31, 2026.

Treschwig said preliminary testing would begin the following week, with additional work planned in November.

The administration hopes to complete the audit before the next statutory deadline in February 2027.

Farno said the city expects its recently completed accounting improvements to address the weaknesses identified in the FY2025 audit.

The next audit will provide an independent assessment of those improvements and a more current picture of the city’s financial position.

Meanwhile, the combination of record sales tax collections, substantial dedicated reserves and approaching tax renewals leaves officials facing a question that emerged repeatedly during Thursday’s meeting: whether Mandeville’s existing revenue structure continues to reflect the city’s most pressing financial needs.

-30-


© 2026 Mandeville Daily. All rights reserved. Republishing permitted with attribution and link to the original article.

"The Prestigious Catahoula Newshound Award. An award I made up, then gave it to myself… five times." — "Wild" Bill Kropog, Editor Emeritus
“The Prestigious Catahoula Newshound Award. An award I made up, then gave it to myself… five times.” — “Wild” Bill Kropog, Editor Emeritus

Judge moves sheriff candidate records lawsuit hearing ahead of election

Court grants request to hear dispute involving Slidell police before Nov. 3 vote

COVINGTON — A judge has moved a hearing in a public records lawsuit involving St. Tammany Parish sheriff candidate Daniel Seuzeneau and the Slidell Police Department to Oct. 28, six days before the Nov. 3 election.

Judge Martin E. Coady signed an order advancing the hearing from its originally scheduled date of Nov. 4, according to documents filed with the St. Tammany Parish Clerk of Court.

The decision follows an Oct. 15 request by attorney Dominick J. Latino III, who argued that voters should have access to public records concerning a candidate before casting their ballots.

The Clerk of Court issued a notice dated Oct. 15 confirming that both Latino’s original petition and his amended petition are scheduled for hearing Oct. 28 at 9:30 a.m. before Coady in Division E of the 22nd Judicial District Court.


Related Coverage: Public records dispute involving sheriff candidate heads to court


Dispute over records remains unresolved

Latino filed the lawsuit Sept. 30, alleging that SPD failed to comply with Louisiana’s Public Records Law in responding to his request for documents concerning Seuzeneau’s nearly 20-year career with the department.

As ⁠Mandeville Daily reported Oct. 16, Latino maintains that the department failed to provide records or written explanations concerning 20 of the 40 categories in his request and provided incomplete responses to the remaining categories.

The request includes personnel records, outside-employment information, departmental communications and police vehicle purchasing records.

SPD notified Latino on Oct. 9 that responsive records had been released through its online portal. Latino acknowledges receiving records but disputes whether the production satisfied the request.

His amended petition asks the court to order production of the outstanding records or require the department to explain whether the documents do not exist, are outside its custody or are being withheld under a legal exemption.

Hearing scheduled before election day but after early voting

Although the hearing will take place six days before the Nov. 3 election, it is scheduled for the day after early voting ends. Early voting began today, Oct. 20, and continues through Tuesday, Oct. 27, meaning voters who cast their ballots early will do so before the court hears the dispute over the requested records.

In seeking an earlier hearing in an amended petition last week, Latino cited Louisiana’s Public Records Law, which provides for preferential consideration of lawsuits seeking enforcement of public records rights.

The original Nov. 4 hearing date would have placed the proceedings one day after the sheriff’s election.

Although the judge granted the request to advance the hearing, the order does not constitute a ruling on whether SPD violated the law.

The Oct. 28 proceeding will give the parties an opportunity to address the allegations and the relief Latino is seeking.

Seuzeneau, who resigned as SPD’s chief administrative officer in July to run for sheriff, has publicly characterized the lawsuit as frivolous. In an Oct. 9 Facebook video, he defended his record of transparency and said the department had made records available through its online portal.

The lawsuit remains pending.

-30-


© 2026 Mandeville Daily. All rights reserved. Republishing permitted with attribution and link to the original article.

"The Prestigious Catahoula Newshound Award. An award I made up, then gave it to myself… five times." — "Wild" Bill Kropog, Editor Emeritus
“The Prestigious Catahoula Newshound Award. An award I made up, then gave it to myself… five times.” — “Wild” Bill Kropog, Editor Emeritus

Public records dispute involving sheriff candidate heads to court

Attorney alleges Slidell police failed to fully respond to records request

Video response challenges lawsuit, raises questions of political motives

Seuzeneau’s employment status questioned in petition

SLIDELL — A public records lawsuit involving St. Tammany Parish sheriff candidate Daniel Seuzeneau and the Slidell Police Department took a new turn Thursday when the attorney who filed the lawsuit asked a judge to move a scheduled hearing to a date before the Nov. 3 sheriff’s election, according to records on file with the St. Tammany Parish Clerk of Court.

The development follows a controversy that erupted on social media last week after Seuzeneau posted a video revealing his inclusion in a lawsuit and questioning its legitimacy.

An Oct. 9 Facebook post by Concerned Citizens of St. Tammany, sharing coverage of sheriff candidate Daniel Seuzeneau’s response to a public records lawsuit, drew comments both supporting and criticizing the candidate, with several commenters alleging political motivations behind the lawsuit. (Mandeville Daily)
An Oct. 9 Facebook post by Concerned Citizens of St. Tammany, sharing coverage of sheriff candidate Daniel Seuzeneau’s response to a public records lawsuit, drew comments both supporting and criticizing the candidate, with several commenters alleging political motivations behind the lawsuit. (Mandeville Daily)

In an amended petition filed Thursday, Oct. 15, attorney Dominick J. Latino III alleges that SPD failed to provide records or written explanations concerning 20 of the 40 categories in his original public records request. He also maintains that the department’s responses to the remaining categories were incomplete.

The lawsuit, filed Sept. 30 in the 22nd Judicial District Court, concerns SPD’s handling of a request for records related to Seuzeneau’s nearly 20-year career with the department.

Download petition filed Sept. 30…
Download amended petition filed Oct. 15…

How the dispute began

According to court filings, Latino submitted his original request Sept. 10 through a contact form on SPD’s website. The request sought personnel and disciplinary records, outside-employment information, departmental communications and records concerning police vehicle purchases and leases.

Latino alleges that SPD did not respond within the time required by Louisiana Public Records Law — five business days.

On Sept. 18, he followed up using the same website form. This time, SPD responded, directing him to submit his request through a different online portal, according to the petition.

Latino complied, submitting the request through the designated portal and sending a physical copy by overnight delivery.

On Sept. 21, SPD acknowledged the request, describing it as “quite voluminous” and estimating that fulfilling it could take up to 14 business days.

Latino filed suit Sept. 30, alleging SPD had failed to comply with the law.

What Seuzeneau said

In an Oct. 9 Facebook video, Seuzeneau characterized the lawsuit as frivolous and questioned why he had been named as a respondent after resigning from SPD in July.

He said he contacted the Slidell city attorney and was informed that the requested records were available through SPD’s online portal.

According to Seuzeneau, Latino needed only to pay the required fee and download the documents.

St. Tammany Parish sheriff candidate Daniel Seuzeneau discusses a public records lawsuit involving his nearly 20-year career with the Slidell Police Department in an Oct. 9 Facebook video. (Mandeville Daily via Facebook)
St. Tammany Parish sheriff candidate Daniel Seuzeneau discusses a public records lawsuit involving his nearly 20-year career with the Slidell Police Department in an Oct. 9 Facebook video. (Mandeville Daily via Facebook)

Seuzeneau also defended his record of transparency, pointing to his years of working with journalists and responding to public records requests. He challenged anyone to find a member of the news media who would say he had not been transparent.

He also offered to publish the requested records on his own website, provided he was entitled to obtain them, so the public could examine his nearly 20-year career with SPD and draw its own conclusions.

Seuzeneau questioned why the request included records involving businessman Matt Bowers and police vehicle purchases. He defended the department’s purchasing practices, saying its vehicles were acquired through state contracts or an Enterprise leasing program.

He suggested political interests might be involved in the lawsuit, although he acknowledged having no proof of who might be responsible.

Why Seuzeneau was named in the lawsuit

Although Seuzeneau resigned as SPD’s chief administrative officer July 21 to run for sheriff, department records show he was appointed that same day to another position.

In his resignation letter, Seuzeneau offered to continue serving the department in a volunteer capacity as Administrative Reserve — Special Assistant to the Chief, assisting with budgeting, financial matters and strategic projects. Police Chief Tommy Williams signed a personnel order appointing him to that position for an indefinite period, directing him to report to Williams for instructions.

Documents filed in the public records lawsuit show Daniel Seuzeneau’s July 21 resignation letter from his position as chief administrative officer of the Slidell Police Department, left, and a personnel order signed the same day by Police Chief Tommy Williams appointing Seuzeneau as Administrative Reserve — Special Assistant to the Chief for an indefinite period, right. (Mandeville Daily excerpts from Slidell Police Department public records.)
Documents filed in the public records lawsuit show Daniel Seuzeneau’s July 21 resignation letter from his position as chief administrative officer of the Slidell Police Department, left, and a personnel order signed the same day by Police Chief Tommy Williams appointing Seuzeneau as Administrative Reserve — Special Assistant to the Chief for an indefinite period, right. (Mandeville Daily excerpts from Slidell Police Department public records.)

During his July 21 public announcement of his candidacy for sheriff, Seuzeneau said he was resigning from SPD but made no mention of his offer to continue serving the department in a volunteer capacity.

In his amended petition, Latino cites correspondence from Seuzeneau’s attorney asserting that his client had no formal connection to SPD after July 20. Latino argues that the personnel order contradicts that assertion and supports keeping Seuzeneau named in the lawsuit until his status and the identity of the department’s public records custodian are clarified.

The filing does not establish that Seuzeneau personally participated in handling the records request.

Louisiana’s civil service restrictions on political activity are intended to preserve political neutrality within government service, not simply to prevent candidates from collecting government paychecks while running for office. That raises a question about whether someone who resigns from a classified civil service position to run for office could continue performing substantially the same duties as an unpaid volunteer without undermining the purpose of those restrictions.

Although Seuzeneau’s appointment to the volunteer position is documented, the personnel order does not specify his duties. It remains unclear whether those duties overlap with his former responsibilities as chief administrative officer or whether the new position is subject to civil service restrictions on political activity.

When were the records released?

The amended petition provides a more precise timeline.

According to an email reproduced in the filing, the City of Slidell notified Latino at 9:17 p.m. Oct. 9 that responsive records had been released through its online portal.

That was nine days after the lawsuit was filed and nearly a month after Latino says he submitted his original request.

Latino acknowledges in his petition that SPD produced records but disputes whether the production satisfied the request.

His amended petition alleges that entire categories of requested documents were omitted, including communications involving Bowers, records concerning outside employment and departmental vehicle purchasing information.

The petition also alleges that SPD failed to explain whether the missing records did not exist, were outside its custody or were being withheld under an exemption.

The department’s production included personnel records, departmental policies, incident reports and other documents, according to the filing.

Why the timing matters

Louisiana’s Public Records Law establishes procedures and deadlines for responding to records requests. Although agencies may need additional time to gather and review extensive records, they must comply with the law’s notification and disclosure requirements.

Louisiana’s Public Records Law generally allows any person to request public records, whether a journalist, political campaign representative, attorney or concerned citizen. A requester is not required to explain why the records are being sought, and public agencies must follow the same legal requirements for responding, regardless of the requester’s identity or motivation.

Latino maintains that the five-business-day response period began Sept. 10, when he says he submitted his original request through SPD’s website, rather than Sept. 18, when he was directed to a different records portal.

Latino argues that SPD’s eventual production does not resolve his allegations concerning delayed responses and missing records.

He is now asking the court to order production of the outstanding records or require SPD to provide written explanations identifying any applicable exemptions or confirming that particular records do not exist.

He also seeks attorney fees, court costs and civil penalties.

Court hearing scheduled after election

The case is currently scheduled for a hearing Nov. 4, one day after the special election for St. Tammany Parish sheriff.

Latino’s amended petition asks Judge Martin E. Coady to move the hearing to a date before the election, arguing that voters should have access to public records concerning a candidate before casting their ballots.

The filing cites a provision of Louisiana law requiring public records enforcement lawsuits to receive preferential consideration.

The judge has not yet granted the request to move the hearing.

Although a court document issued Oct. 9 is formally titled “Writ of Mandamus,” it directs SPD and the other named respondents to comply with the petition’s demands or appear in court to explain why they should not be required to do so.

It does not constitute a ruling that SPD violated Louisiana Public Records Law.

The central question remains whether SPD properly handled Latino’s request and whether additional records or explanations must be provided.

-30-


© 2026 Mandeville Daily. All rights reserved. Republishing permitted with attribution and link to the original article.

"The Prestigious Catahoula Newshound Award. An award I made up, then gave it to myself… five times." — "Wild" Bill Kropog, Editor Emeritus
“The Prestigious Catahoula Newshound Award. An award I made up, then gave it to myself… five times.” — “Wild” Bill Kropog, Editor Emeritus

Madden-Berning dispute takes new turn over text message records

Berning’s attorney alleges destruction of public records in letter

City rejects claim, says mayor’s messages stay in cloud storage

Mayor provides police with text exchanges dating to 2024

MANDEVILLE — The ongoing dispute between Mayor Clay Madden and local businessman Robert “Trey” Berning III has taken another turn, with an exchange of letters between attorneys and additional text messages entered into a police report.

The developments came to light after Mandeville Daily contacted Madden to follow up on its Aug. 25 story concerning a police report he filed documenting what he described as an escalating dispute with Berning.

Madden disclosed that an attorney representing Berning had questioned his handling of text messages after the original police report mentioned that messages automatically delete from his cellphone after 30 days.

Madden said the messages had never been destroyed and that the setting concerned only how long they remained stored on his phone. He said his messages were maintained through cloud storage.

Madden subsequently provided police with earlier text exchanges between himself and Berning to amend his earlier report in order to clarify the record.

Mandeville Daily obtained the supplemental police report and its attachments, along with the attorney correspondence, through public records requests.

Download Berning’s attorney’s letter…
Download city attorney’s response…
Download Madden’s amended police report…

Attorney challenges handling of messages

In a Sept. 9 letter, attorney William Most, who identified himself as Berning’s attorney, accused Madden of knowingly allowing public records to be destroyed, citing Madden’s statement in the original police report that text messages automatically deleted from his cellphone after 30 days.

“It is also a fact that you have knowingly permitted the destruction of public records on that phone,” Most wrote.

Most argued that communications concerning official city business remain public records regardless of whether they are maintained on a government-issued or personal device. He demanded Madden either disable automatic deletion or ensure the records were preserved elsewhere.

City Attorney Elizabeth Sconzert rejected the allegation in a Sept. 28 response.

“No public records were destroyed,” Sconzert wrote, explaining that Madden’s messages concerning public business are maintained in cloud storage even though they automatically delete from his cellphone after 30 days.

“The 30-day automatic-deletion setting referenced in your letter does not mean that those public-business messages were destroyed; he simply does not store them on his device ad infinitum,” Sconzert wrote.

She added that the city would continue preserving public records in accordance with applicable law and invited Berning to submit a public records request for any particular records he sought.

Most, contacted by Mandeville Daily for comment on his allegations and the city’s response, declined to comment.

Text messages added to police report

Before the city formally responded to Most’s letter, Madden contacted Mandeville Police Capt. James Lord on Sept. 16 to supplement his original report with copies of text messages between himself and Berning that had been maintained in his iCloud account.

The messages included those concerning the sign-permit dispute raised in Most’s letter, along with earlier exchanges dating to August 2024 that provide additional context about the relationship between the two men.

Those earlier messages also establish a connection to a previous police incident involving Berning.

Messages connect to 2024 tree-cutting incident

According to the messages provided by Madden, on Aug. 2, 2024, Berning contacted him seeking assistance obtaining a city permit while a tree crew was working at Berning’s property.

According to the messages, Berning explained that his insurance company required removal of pine trees from the property and that the arborist “didn’t know he needed” a permit.

Berning said the crew needed the permit that day so it could “finish the job.”

Madden responded that the city did not issue the permits the same day but said he had contacted the Planning Department and asked that Berning’s application be processed as quickly as possible.

“Thank you very much. Have a safe trip,” Berning responded.

The exchange occurred on the same date as a separate Mandeville Police Department incident involving tree removal at Berning’s property without the required permit.

That police report, obtained incidentally by Mandeville Daily as part of its earlier public records request concerning this dispute, documents that Berning and the tree contractor were cited in connection with the violation.

The text messages appear to show that Berning contacted Madden seeking assistance with the permit during the same tree-removal episode that resulted in police enforcement action.

The messages also show that the relationship between Madden and Berning was cordial at the time. Madden attempted to have the permit application expedited through the Planning Department, and Berning thanked him.

Other messages show the two continued communicating before their exchanges increasingly centered on Berning’s disputes with the city, including issues involving his business and signage.

Madden’s original police report documented a series of interactions with Berning, including a dispute involving signage at Berning’s business, the projection of the words “FIRE CLAY MADDEN” onto a building and an encounter Madden said occurred at The Salad Station in August 2025.

The supplemental police report also includes Madden’s account of two additional encounters with Berning, on Aug. 17 and Sept. 14, during which Madden alleges Berning made obscene hand gestures toward him. Madden said his 10-year-old daughter witnessed the second incident.

Mandeville Daily has not independently verified either allegation, and the report does not indicate whether police investigated the encounters. Most, who was provided a copy of the supplemental report and specifically asked to comment on its contents, declined to do so.

-30-


© 2026 Mandeville Daily. All rights reserved. Republishing permitted with attribution and link to the original article.

"The Prestigious Catahoula Newshound Award. An award I made up, then gave it to myself… five times." — "Wild" Bill Kropog, Editor Emeritus
“The Prestigious Catahoula Newshound Award. An award I made up, then gave it to myself… five times.” — “Wild” Bill Kropog, Editor Emeritus

OPINION | Somebody forgot to tell Old Mandeville businesses they’re struggling

Discon cites his own coffee shop and empty restaurants during off-hours as signs of trouble

Citywide sales tax collections exceed budget and prior-year levels

There was nothing particularly remarkable about the Mandeville City Council considering another whole-house short-term rental in Old Mandeville at its Sept. 24 meeting.

The city has allowed them under a tightly controlled system since 2020. The original ordinance capped whole-house rentals at 10, in part because the council recognized that an excessive number could affect the character and tranquility of residential neighborhoods.

Last year, the council increased that cap to 20.

So when the council considered a conditional-use permit for a whole-house rental at 538 Girod St., the application was hardly breaking new ground. Eighteen applications have already been approved, making this the prospective 19th of the 20 allowed. The Planning Commission had recommended approval 7-0.

But Councilman-at-Large Scott Discon made the discussion about something else… himself.

“I used to own a coffee shop for three years,” Discon said. “It’s hard to own a business in Old Mandeville.”

Then came the assertion that deserves considerably more scrutiny:

“You’ve got a business district that’s struggling. I don’t care what anyone says.”

Diners enjoying Rusty Pelican during a busy lunch hour. (Mandeville Daily/Rusty Pelican)
Diners enjoying Rusty Pelican during a busy lunch hour. (Mandeville Daily/Rusty Pelican)

Discon pointed to Mandeville’s lack of a hotel and contrasted Old Mandeville with Covington. He encouraged people to spend time in Old Mandeville and observe the restaurants.

“When you see that there’s no one in the restaurant from 1:30 to 5:00, you tell me how you think they’re going to make it,” he said.

So according to his reasoning, because owning a coffee shop was hard and people don’t eat meals at 3 p.m., Mandeville has a struggling business district.

Perhaps this is simply the beginning of the 2028 election cycle — with no one yet saying exactly which office they intend to seek — when declaring Mandeville to be in trouble becomes much more politically useful than acknowledging the reality on the ground.

If Old Mandeville can’t support businesses, somebody forgot to tell the businesses

If the district itself is the problem, Old Mandeville has produced a remarkable number of exceptions.

Nuvolari’s has operated since 1983. Rip’s on the Lake has been a lakefront fixture for decades. The Rusty Pelican has built a lasting business selling hamburgers, sandwiches and other casual fare. Pat’s Rest Awhile has established itself as a lakefront destination. La Lou, a breakfast and brunch restaurant on Girod Street, has likewise become a popular Old Mandeville destination. And let’s not forget about the Barley Oak, the Grapeful Ape or Aperitif Spritz & Bites.

And just a few blocks from Discon’s former coffee shop sits The Bean, another independent coffee shop that has thrived in Old Mandeville since 2019.

Discon’s own experience with his coffee shop also deserves some context.

When The Scotts’ closed in December 2015, his partner Scott Williams told The Times-Picayune that the business had lost its lease. Williams said he and Discon had no immediate plans to reopen elsewhere and would “take a step back and regroup” before deciding how to proceed. The newspaper also reported that The Scotts’ had expanded into adjoining space after opening in 2012 and described its final day as one of its busiest, with loyal customers coming to say goodbye.

What happened at the location afterward is perhaps even more telling. After The Scotts’ Coffee Bar closed, The Candy Bank opened there. Nearly a decade later, it remains in business and has earned national recognition, placing sixth in USA Today’s 2024 10Best Readers’ Choice Awards for best candy store.

But Discon’s statement about the absence of a hotel omitted a significant development. The city approved a 10-room boutique hotel for the top floor of the St. Tammany Bank Building, Discon’s former location, in January 2023, and by June 2025, city records described the project as under development, with a permit already issued.

All these businesses operate within the same streets, the same geography, and the same lack of a conventional hotel.

They found a way to make it work.

At the Sept. 24 council meeting, Finance Director Jessica Farno reported preliminary FY2026 sales-tax collections of $23.05 million — about $1.24 million higher than the previous year and above the city’s adjusted budget. She also said recent monthly collections had been running “well above” budget targets.

That is hardly evidence of a “struggling” business district. The things Discon pointed out are simply proof of how difficult operating a successful business can be, at least from his perspective.

Mandeville is not an island or some remote destination where visitors need hotel rooms to patronize local businesses. Old Mandeville draws day-trippers from neighboring communities and unincorporated St. Tammany Parish, as well as farther afield — Baton Rouge, Hammond, Washington Parish and southern Mississippi.

And we have yet to see the full economic impact of the new Trader Joe’s. The store is another reason for people throughout the region to visit Mandeville, creating opportunities for nearby Old Mandeville restaurants and shops to attract some of those visitors.

An empty restaurant at 3 p.m. proves very little

Discon’s observation about restaurants being empty between 1:30 and 5 p.m. is particularly unconvincing.

Seeing an empty dining room at 3 p.m. only confirms that people typically don’t eat meals at that time of day, not that the restaurant is struggling or about to go under.

Does he truly expect one additional year-round Airbnb to prompt a wave of guests crowding dining rooms during mid-afternoons when people aren’t hungry?

Discon’s three years as a coffee-shop owner gives him legitimate firsthand experience with the difficulty of operating a small business. No doubt.

But what in the world does that have to do with filling one additional short-term-rental space — among 20 already designated by the council in prior years for that aim?

Give people a reason to come

There is also a larger question about what actually creates economic activity.

Certainly, short-term rentals contribute something. Visitors staying overnight eat at restaurants, buy coffee and spend money. That is a legitimate economic benefit.

But scale that beyond a certain point in a place like Old Mandeville, and you risk diminishing the very thing that attracts people here in the first place.

Mandeville has invested heavily in public infrastructure and amenities over the years, particularly under Mayor Clay Madden, and that spending sometimes draws criticism. Yet there is another way to view those investments.

The lakefront, Harbor Field, Sunset Point, parks, playgrounds and other public spaces help give people a reason to come to Mandeville. Its distinctive collection of restaurants and shops gives them even more reason to stay and spend money.

The challenge is preserving the idyllic character of Old Mandeville and the lakefront while continuing to invest in the things that make people want to be here. In the pursuit of economic development, we should be careful not to kill the golden goose.

And putting a large traditional hotel on the lakefront may very well do just that. Mandeville has already had that debate. The rejected Sucette Harbor development proposed a large hotel on the western end of the lakefront.

Political ambition should never come at the expense of the community

It was unnecessary to use an otherwise routine short-term-rental application to shoehorn a non-existent crisis into the discussion by declaring Old Mandeville a “business district that’s struggling.”

It was an insult to all those businesses that have succeeded and become part of what makes Mandeville a destination.

Some businesses make it. Others don’t. Some survive 40 years. Others close within months. Some people are good at it. Others aren’t. That’s the way it is everywhere, not just in Old Mandeville.

And perhaps the most telling part of Discon’s statement, regardless of which office he intends to seek, was the four words he inserted after declaring the district was struggling:

“I don’t care what anyone says.”

We do.

-30-


© 2026 Mandeville Daily. All rights reserved. Republishing permitted with attribution and link to the original article.

"The Prestigious Catahoula Newshound Award. An award I made up, then gave it to myself… five times." — "Wild" Bill Kropog, Editor Emeritus
“The Prestigious Catahoula Newshound Award. An award I made up, then gave it to myself… five times.” — “Wild” Bill Kropog, Editor Emeritus

Mandeville closes fiscal year with sales tax growth, heavy capital spending

Preliminary year-end figures outperform budget projections as city closes books on FY2026

Capital spending drives fund balance decline, with millions reimbursed through dedicated taxes and grant

MANDEVILLE — The City of Mandeville ended its 2026 fiscal year with sales tax collections up $1.24 million from the previous year and slightly above its adjusted budget, while preliminary figures show the city spent more than $17 million on capital projects and assets during the year.

Finance Director Jessica Farno presented the preliminary year-end financial report to the City Council Thursday night, cautioning that the figures could change as the city completes its year-end closing process and makes audit adjustments.

Sales and use tax collections totaled $23.05 million for the fiscal year ending Aug. 31, while property tax collections totaled $2.25 million, about $72,000 above budget.

Across the city’s governmental funds, revenues totaled $34.13 million and operating expenditures were $25.19 million. The city also recorded $17.2 million in capital outlay during the year.

Governmental fund balances declined by $8.26 million, less than the $9.82 million decrease projected in the city’s revised budget. Farno emphasized that the decline came during a year in which the city spent heavily on capital projects and other assets.

The General Fund showed a preliminary decrease of $1.32 million, including $9.62 million in capital spending. Farno said roughly $5 million of that spending was reimbursed through the city’s special sales tax funds, with additional reimbursements coming from grants.

Farno told the council the preliminary General Fund result could improve considerably as the city finishes reconciling grant revenue associated with projects completed during the fiscal year.

“This number I would expect to change a little bit, probably get closer to a net even, possibly even a net increase,” Farno said.

She explained that expenses generally are recorded as invoices arrive, while some grant revenues associated with capital projects cannot be recognized until the city completes its reconciliation process.

Water and sewer remain in the red

The water and sewer system remained in the red, but its preliminary $1.62 million loss was about $380,000 less than what the city had budgeted.

The enterprise fund generated $4.56 million in revenue and recorded $6.17 million in operating expenses, including depreciation, resulting in a preliminary loss of $1.62 million. The city’s budget had anticipated a loss of approximately $2 million even after the utility rate changes implemented during the year.

Water revenue came in slightly above budget, while sewer revenue remained below budget.

District I Councilwoman Cynthia Strong-Thompson questioned why the system remained substantially in the red despite what she calculated as approximately a 23% year-over-year increase in water collections.

Farno said the problem appeared to be primarily on the sewer side.

“I think it’s almost all tied to sewer income not being where it needs to be,” Farno said.

Mayor Clay Madden said the city is moving forward with a second review of its water and sewer rates after accumulating a full year of operating data under the current rate structure.

The council authorized the review earlier this year following complaints from some residents about utility bills.

Madden said the city’s original rate study was funded by the state and conducted by Manchac Consulting Group. He said other Louisiana municipalities and parish governments that underwent similar studies also are seeking a second review after operating under their new rates.

“We’ve been through a year. We wanna get a second set of eyes to come in and reevaluate and make sure that we did things correctly,” Madden said.

Council weighs short-term rental limit

The council also approved the city’s 19th whole-house short-term rental permit Thursday while postponing action on an application that would fill the 20th and final slot currently authorized by the city.

Ordinance 26-35, allowing a whole-house rental at 538 Girod St., received unanimous approval.

The Mandeville City Council approved a whole-house short-term rental at 538 Girod St. Thursday, bringing the city to 19 approved permits under its current 20-permit cap. (Mandeville Daily/Apple Maps)
The Mandeville City Council approved a whole-house short-term rental at 538 Girod St. Thursday, bringing the city to 19 approved permits under its current 20-permit cap. (Mandeville Daily/Apple Maps)

The application prompted council members to discuss whether the city should stop at its current limit of 20 permits rather than increasing the cap again.

District II Councilman Kevin Vogeltanz, who previously opposed increasing the limit from 10 to 20, said he would be reluctant to authorize additional permits after the remaining slot is filled.

“When we fill out these 20, I’m gonna be hard-pressed to approve any more,” Vogeltanz said.

District III Councilwoman Jill Lane expressed a similar view.

“Let’s cap it at 20,” Lane said, while noting that she has not received complaints about existing short-term rentals.

Planning Director Cara Bartholomew recommended allowing the existing program to operate for a period before the council considers another increase. She said the city waited approximately two years before increasing the original limit and has experienced few problems with the permitted rentals.

Councilman-at-Large Scott Discon defended the rentals as a source of customers for Old Mandeville businesses, particularly because the city does not have a hotel.

20th permit postponed

The council then considered Ordinance 26-36, which would authorize a whole-house short-term rental at 1939 Lakeshore Drive and fill the city’s 20th available permit.

Planning and Zoning recommended approval, and Bartholomew said the city received no opposition from neighboring property owners.

The City Council postponed action on a proposed whole-house short-term rental at 1939 Lakeshore Drive until Oct. 8. If approved, the property would become the city’s 20th permitted whole-house short-term rental. (Mandeville Daily/Apple Maps)
The City Council postponed action on a proposed whole-house short-term rental at 1939 Lakeshore Drive until Oct. 8. If approved, the property would become the city’s 20th permitted whole-house short-term rental. (Mandeville Daily/Apple Maps)

Council members, however, began questioning where the property owners would live after converting the house to a short-term rental and who would be responsible for managing it.

After reviewing the application during the meeting, Bartholomew read a statement indicating that the owners would not reside locally and intended to hire a professional short-term rental management service. The application did not yet identify the management company or local contact.

Vogeltanz said he wanted the applicants to appear before the council before a decision was made.

“They’re not here. They haven’t listed a management company. They haven’t listed emergency contacts,” Vogeltanz said. “I would like to give them the opportunity to appear.”

The council unanimously postponed the application until its Oct. 8 meeting and requested that the applicants attend and provide information identifying who would oversee the property.

The city therefore remains at 19 approved whole-house short-term rental permits.

Councilman-at-Large Jason Zuckerman was absent from Thursday’s meeting.

-30-


© 2026 Mandeville Daily. All rights reserved. Republishing permitted with attribution and link to the original article.

"The Prestigious Catahoula Newshound Award. An award I made up, then gave it to myself… five times." — "Wild" Bill Kropog, Editor Emeritus
“The Prestigious Catahoula Newshound Award. An award I made up, then gave it to myself… five times.” — “Wild” Bill Kropog, Editor Emeritus

Rhinehart reappointed to Mandeville Planning and Zoning Commission

Council members unanimously back longtime commissioner as city continues work on zoning rewrite

MANDEVILLE — The Mandeville City Council unanimously reappointed Brian Rhinehart​ to the city’s Planning and Zoning Commission on Thursday, keeping an experienced member in place as the city continues work on a rewrite of its zoning regulations.

All five council members nominated Rhinehart under the council’s recently adopted procedure for filling board and commission seats. Council members cited Rhinehart’s experience, leadership and knowledge of the city’s land-use regulations as reasons for supporting his reappointment.

Brian Reinhardt addresses the Mandeville City Council on Thursday after council members unanimously voted to reappoint him to the city’s Planning and Zoning Commission. (Mandeville Daily)
Brian Reinhardt addresses the Mandeville City Council on Thursday after council members unanimously voted to reappoint him to the city’s Planning and Zoning Commission. (Mandeville Daily)

Council members also praised applicants Charles Guinchard and Dennis Horchoff for seeking the position and suggested they could be considered for other opportunities to serve the city, including vacancies on the Historic District Commission.

Planning and Zoning commissioners serve seven-year terms and receive $100 per month.

-30-


© 2026 Mandeville Daily. All rights reserved. Republishing permitted with attribution and link to the original article.

"The Prestigious Catahoula Newshound Award. An award I made up, then gave it to myself… five times." — "Wild" Bill Kropog, Editor Emeritus
“The Prestigious Catahoula Newshound Award. An award I made up, then gave it to myself… five times.” — “Wild” Bill Kropog, Editor Emeritus

Mandeville adopts FY2027 budget with 2.8% employee COLA

Discon promised specific cuts after alleging city was overspending but never produced them, ultimately citing audit in lone no vote

MANDEVILLE — The Mandeville City Council adopted a structurally balanced operating budget for the coming fiscal year Thursday, ending weeks of hearings that began with Councilman-at-Large Scott Discon insisting the city was overspending and promising to identify specific areas where spending should be cut.

Those specific expenditure cuts never materialized.

Instead, as the hearings progressed, other council members generally praised the administration’s proposed budget during the series of five budget hearings, and Discon himself eventually acknowledged he could not identify any significant operating reductions.

By the final hearing Thursday, Discon only proposed broad reductions to categories of spending rather than specific expenditures, repeatedly looked to capital spending for savings that city officials explained could not offset recurring operating expenses, and ultimately supported an amendment increasing the employee cost-of-living adjustment from 1% to 2.8%.

It was Councilman-at-Large Jason Zuckerman, who had defended the administration’s proposed budget against Discon’s overspending claims, who ultimately identified specific operating expenditures that could be reduced to help pay for the larger annual cost of living adjustment (COLA).

Then, immediately before the final vote, Discon cited a different objection to the operating budget: The city’s completed FY2025 audit had not yet been formally published.

The operating budget passed 4-1, with Discon casting the lone vote against it. He also cast the lone vote against the city’s FY2027 capital budget.

The Mandeville City Council adopted the city’s FY2027 operating budget Thursday in a 4-1 vote. Council members Jason Zuckerman, Cynthia Strong-Thompson, Kevin Vogeltanz and Jill Lane voted in favor, while Councilman-at-Large Scott Discon cast the lone vote against the spending plan. (Mandeville Daily)
The Mandeville City Council adopted the city’s FY2027 operating budget Thursday in a 4-1 vote. Council members Jason Zuckerman, Cynthia Strong-Thompson, Kevin Vogeltanz and Jill Lane voted in favor, while Councilman-at-Large Scott Discon cast the lone vote against the spending plan. (Mandeville Daily)

A structurally balanced proposal

Mayor Clay Madden’s proposed FY2027 operating budget entered the hearings with recurring revenues exceeding recurring operating expenses by approximately $200,000.

The administration had already identified approximately $530,000 in recurring personnel and discretionary General Fund reductions while developing the proposal.

Personnel savings included leaving a finance data entry clerk and one police officer position unfunded. Madden has said the police reduction is effectively offset by the addition of a sergeant to supervise school resource officers, with the St. Tammany Parish School Board paying 10 months of the position’s annual cost and the city responsible for the remaining two months.

Other reductions included nearly $80,000 in legal fees, $75,000 in planning and development, $50,000 in audit and accounting fees and reductions in spending for the Trailhead, Community Center, advertising, banquets, travel and memberships.

The reductions also addressed several areas that Civil Service representatives and others had earlier pointed to as places the city could trim spending to provide a larger employee COLA. During the hearings, suggestions included reducing travel and other discretionary spending and questioning spending on amenities and events.

But Madden and Finance Director Jessica Farno said many of those choices had already been made before the proposed budget ever reached the council. Madden said the administration had spent months working through different scenarios to bring recurring expenses below recurring revenues, including reducing travel and overtime and making what he described as difficult spending decisions.

The resulting proposal already reduced spending for the Trailhead, Community Center, advertising, banquets, travel and memberships, along with larger reductions in legal, planning, audit and accounting expenses.

The approximately $200,000 difference between recurring revenue and expenses was relatively small, but it represented a significant change from previous budgets.

“This is the first year in many years that we … are paying for recurring expenses with recurring revenue,” Zuckerman said during the first hearing.

Farno confirmed that assessment.

District I Councilwoman Cynthia Strong-Thompson described the $200,000 margin as a “squeaker,” noting that unexpected overtime or other expenses could quickly consume it.

Discon says city is still overspending

Despite the reductions and structurally balanced proposal, Discon said during the Aug. 13 hearing that he believed the city was still spending too much.

“And I still think- We’re s- we’re overspending. We should be saving some money somewhere,” Discon said. “I still think that there’s some overspending in this thing.”

Madden pressed Discon to identify it.

“I need from you, Councilman Discon, the areas that you feel like we’re overspending,” Madden said.

Discon said he would provide them.

“We don’t have the time right now for me to go into that, but I’m putting together a list of what I think we should be doing, and that will come to the next meeting,” Discon said.

He later noted that three hearings remained and said he still had time “to put all that together.”

Zuckerman questioned why the assertion had been made before the supporting details were available.

“If I was gonna come to a budget hearing and claim that we’re overspending and the budget is overspent, and this budget is overspending, and that the forecast is inaccurate, I would certainly have some details with me to do it,” Zuckerman said.

No ‘big change’ found in operating budget

The promised list did not emerge at the next hearing Aug. 19.

After reviewing the operating budget, Discon instead acknowledged he could not see where significant changes could be made.

“We went through the operational tonight,” Discon said. “I don’t see where we could make any big change. I guess we’d have to look at capital.”

Zuckerman reminded Discon of his earlier promise.

“In the last meeting, you had indicated that in this budget, you were going to come prepared with proposed cuts,” Zuckerman said.

Zuckerman said if Discon had reviewed the spending since the previous hearing and concluded the operating budget was sound, that was an acceptable answer, but he wanted to “close the loop” so the public would not be confused.

Discon responded that he could not remember all of the specifics surrounding the previous year’s budget debate and asked that his explanation be accepted so the council could move forward.

The exchange also highlighted a similar dispute during the previous year’s budget process.

Zuckerman noted that approximately $2.2 million in operating reductions had been proposed during the FY2026 process, but Discon voted against those proposed reductions before ultimately voting against the operating budget itself. Discon voted for the FY2026 capital budget.

Larger COLA raises question of recurring revenue

The spending question changed during the later hearings as council members considered increasing the administration’s proposed 1% employee COLA to 2.8%, matching the Social Security Administration’s 2026 adjustment and the recommendation of Mandeville’s Municipal Employees and Police Employees Civil Service Boards from Aug. 19.

The additional 1.8 percentage points would cost the General Fund approximately $200,000 annually — potentially consuming virtually all of the administration’s recurring operating cushion.

District III Councilwoman Jill Lane discusses the FY2027 budget during an Aug. 19 hearing. Lane said the city should consider increasing property tax millages closer to their voter-authorized levels in future years to generate recurring revenue for employee cost-of-living adjustments. (Mandeville Daily)
District III Councilwoman Jill Lane discusses the FY2027 budget during an Aug. 19 hearing. Lane said the city should consider increasing property tax millages closer to their voter-authorized levels in future years to generate recurring revenue for employee cost-of-living adjustments. (Mandeville Daily)

District III Councilwoman Jill Lane supported the full 2.8%, arguing the city should maintain the compensation gains made since an earlier salary study brought employee pay closer to comparable municipalities.

Lane also looked beyond the current budget for a longer-term way to pay for future COLAs, pointing to property tax millages the city has historically levied below their voter-authorized levels. Lane said the council would have an opportunity to adjust those millages next year and acknowledged that doing so would not be popular.

“I do feel it is our responsibility … to find the revenue,” Lane said, adding that the city needs to consider ways to increase recurring revenue rather than allowing employee compensation to again fall behind.

Zuckerman also supported the larger COLA but said he would not vote for it without finding recurring operating savings to offset at least part of the additional cost.

“If the COLA’s gonna cost us about $200,000 a year … we need to find $200,000 or I’m not gonna vote for it, and I’m not gonna do it by just saying, ‘Administration, go figure it out,’” Zuckerman said.

“That’s our job.”

Discon proposes categories, not expenditures

At Thursday’s final hearing, Discon returned to his contention that spending should be reduced but did not identify a specific operating expenditure he wanted the council to eliminate.

Instead, he proposed removing $300,000 generally from General Fund spending and leaving the administration to decide where the reductions would fall.

“What line item is it, Mr. Chairman?” Zuckerman asked.

“It’s just a general $300,000,” Discon responded. “It’s up to the administration to figure out how they wanna divvy that up amongst their line items… I don’t wanna be the one to make that decision.”

Discon said he did not want to be the person making those individual decisions.


I don’t wanna be the one to make that decision.

— Councilman-at-Large Scott Discon


“I don’t have to back it up with anything more than the fact that I think we’re still overspending,” Discon said.

Discon separately proposed reducing by half approximately $1.28 million in equipment purchases from the Special Sales Tax Fund, again suggesting that department officials determine which purchases to eliminate.

Zuckerman rejected the broader approach to the operating budget, saying deciding what to eliminate was the council’s responsibility.

“I’ve got four individual line items that I could propose right now rather than just say, ‘Go figure it out, Mr. Mayor,’” Zuckerman said.

Capital reductions can’t offset COLA

Discon also repeatedly looked to the capital budget as a potential source of savings to accommodate the larger employee COLA.

He had first suggested that approach Aug. 19 after saying he could not identify any “big change” in the operating budget, suggesting the city might delay a truck or another capital purchase.

At the final hearing, Discon again suggested reducing capital projects and equipment purchases.

But Farno explained that none of those capital purchases were included in recurring operating expenses.

“So that would have no impact on the $200,000 budget?” Zuckerman asked.

“Correct,” Farno responded.

The distinction surfaced again when Discon objected to reducing landscape maintenance and suggested instead taking $50,000 from the design of a park.

Public Works Director Keith LaGrange told Discon that cutting the capital project “does not help your recurring operating expenses.”

Planning Director Cara Bartholomew then reiterated the distinction.

“Jessica said over and over and over again that cutting something in the capital budget has no effect on the operating budget,” Bartholomew said.


You have to stay in the same piece of paper.

— Planning Director Cara Bartholomew


“If you want to increase the operating budget, then you need to decrease the operating budget if you wanna make that balance,” she said. “You have to stay in the same piece of paper.”

The distinction was critical because the COLA represents a recurring personnel expense. Eliminating a one-time capital purchase can reduce overall spending in a particular year, but it does not provide recurring savings to support the higher payroll in future years.

Zuckerman identifies specific cuts

Zuckerman was ultimately the only council member to propose specific operating expenditures for reduction as the council searched for money to offset the larger COLA.

His initial suggestions included planning and development, landscape maintenance, Trailhead concerts, decor and beautification and even eliminating the $72,000 budgeted for council members’ pay for one year.

Not all of the proposals survived scrutiny. City officials explained that some would reduce services or involved expenses with corresponding revenue.

The discussion nevertheless produced a package of specific operating changes.

The final amendment removed $43,670 from a comprehensive plan revision, $50,000 from planning and development, $35,000 from decor and beautification and $20,300 from building maintenance. It also added $20,000 for social services.

The net reduction was $128,970.

“So we’d be increasing the budget by about $200,000 for the 2.8% COLA, but then saving $129,000 back in that same amendment,” Zuckerman said as he assembled the changes into an amendment to Lane’s pending COLA amendment.

Strong-Thompson seconded the amendment.

The procedural discussion became confused at several points as the council worked through the amendments required before it could adopt the final ordinance.

Zuckerman, who served as council chairman before Discon, repeatedly clarified the sequence for incorporating the spending changes into Lane’s pending amendment and then voting on the amended budget ordinance. District II Councilman Kevin Vogeltanz also reminded Discon when public comment or a vote on a pending amendment was still required before the council could proceed.

Earlier in the final budget hearing, Discon had asked Zuckerman for help determining how the amendments should be handled, noting Zuckerman had chaired the council the previous year. Zuckerman explained that the council could discuss the proposals during the hearing but could not vote until the ordinances were formally before it during the regular meeting.

The amendment incorporating the specific reductions into Lane’s 2.8% COLA proposal ultimately passed 4-1.

Lane, Strong-Thompson, Zuckerman and Discon voted for it. Vogeltanz voted against it.

Audit objection overrides support for COLA

After weeks of hearings that began with Discon’s assertion that the city was overspending, excessive spending was not the reason he cited immediately before voting against the final operating budget.

Instead, Discon pointed to the city’s FY2025 audit.

The audit had been completed earlier that day following an exit conference with the city’s auditor and was scheduled to be submitted to the Louisiana Legislative Auditor and Federal Audit Clearinghouse the following day. Madden said the city could not publish the audit on its website until it cleared the Legislative Auditor process, although council members could review the completed document in Farno’s office in the interim.

“I’m still having an issue with we don’t have a true audit that’s been published,” Discon said before the final vote.

Although Discon had just voted for the amendment providing employees the 2.8% COLA, he then voted against the operating budget containing it. His no vote did not affect the outcome because the other four council members supported the final ordinance.

But the vote was not merely symbolic: Had opposition from other council members left Discon as the deciding vote, rejection of the operating budget would also have prevented the COLA amendment he said he supported from actually taking effect.

Discon said he supported the employee COLA and appreciated the work that had gone into finding money for it, but said he had “a principle” he wanted to stand behind for residents.

The completed audit had also improved the financial picture used to construct the budget. Madden said the audited General Fund balance was approximately $1 million higher than the conservative estimate used during budget preparation.

Farno explained that the additional fund balance strengthened the city’s reserves but did not increase recurring revenue or change the recurring operating balance.

The council adopted the operating budget 4-1.

Lane, Vogeltanz, Strong-Thompson and Zuckerman voted for it. Discon voted against it.

The vote produced an unusual split: Vogeltanz opposed the amendment increasing the COLA to 2.8% but supported the final budget once the council adopted the increase. Discon supported the COLA amendment but voted against the resulting budget.

Capital budget also passes 4-1

The council next considered the FY2027 capital budget.

Its reception from the other council members had been notably positive.

During the previous night’s hearing, Vogeltanz called it “a very good capital budget” and said he could not think of a reason to remove money from the city’s planned investments in infrastructure and amenities.

During Thursday’s adoption meeting, Strong-Thompson said the city was “investing in the future,” Vogeltanz again called the infrastructure and amenity investments “a good use,” Lane said she was ready to vote and Zuckerman said he had no remaining issues with the capital budget.

The council made several technical corrections, including carrying forward previously appropriated money for the Jackson Avenue bulkhead and North Causeway fencing, correcting a lift station appropriation and renaming another project.

Discon joined the other four council members in unanimously approving those amendments.

The final capital budget then passed 4-1, with Discon again casting the lone vote against it.

Discon did not separately explain during the capital-budget discussion why he opposed the final plan.

Mayor’s compensation increased

The council also amended Madden’s compensation during the budget process.

Madden received the same 2.8% COLA approved for employees along with a 4% merit increase. The council also doubled his annual vehicle allowance from $6,000 to $12,000.

The changes bring Madden’s salary to approximately $129,333, excluding the vehicle allowance.

The FY2027 budget takes effect Oct. 1.

-30-


© 2026 Mandeville Daily. All rights reserved. Republishing permitted with attribution and link to the original article.

"The Prestigious Catahoula Newshound Award. An award I made up, then gave it to myself… five times." — "Wild" Bill Kropog, Editor Emeritus
“The Prestigious Catahoula Newshound Award. An award I made up, then gave it to myself… five times.” — “Wild” Bill Kropog, Editor Emeritus

Council members propose new spending as Mandeville budget heads to final hearing

Proposed additions could erase $200,000 cushion, push praised budget well into the red

MANDEVILLE — After weeks of debate over whether Mandeville is spending too much, City Council members emerged from their fourth budget hearing Wednesday without identifying a specific spending cut — but with several proposals to add expenses to Mayor Clay Madden’s proposed FY2027 budget.

Councilman-at-Large Scott Discon, who earlier this month said the city was overspending and told Madden he would identify areas to cut as the hearings continued, instead announced Wednesday that he plans to seek $15,000 for equipment to water city trees, despite Public Works Director Keith LaGrange telling him the city already has equipment for the job.

District III Councilwoman Jill Lane said she will propose increasing the city’s employee cost-of-living adjustment from the 1% included in Madden’s budget to 2.8%, an increase she and Finance Director Jessica Farno discussed as adding roughly $200,000 in General Fund expenses. Without corresponding cuts, the increase would consume essentially all of the roughly $200,000 operating cushion in the proposed budget.

And District II Councilman Kevin Vogeltanz said he plans to propose increasing the mayor’s salary and vehicle allowance, arguing Mandeville risks discouraging qualified candidates from seeking the city’s top elected position in future elections if its compensation continues to lag behind senior city employees. Madden did not include a pay raise for himself in the FY2027 budget he presented to the council.

Mandeville Police Chief Todd Schliem answers council members’ questions about Police Department spending line items during Wednesday’s fourth FY2027 budget hearing. (Mandeville Daily)
Mandeville Police Chief Todd Schliem answers council members’ questions about Police Department spending line items during Wednesday’s fourth FY2027 budget hearing. (Mandeville Daily)

Neither Councilmen-at-Large Jason Zuckerman nor District I Councilwoman Cynthia Strong-Thompson proposed additional spending Wednesday, instead praising the administration’s work on the proposed budget.

The proposals are expected to be formally considered Thursday during the council’s fifth and final budget hearing at 4 p.m., immediately before its regular 6 p.m. meeting.

The proposed additions came after Madden opened Wednesday’s hearing with a detailed accounting of reductions he and Farno said were already incorporated into the budget before it was presented to the council June 30.

Madden said the administration identified approximately $233,000 in personnel reductions and $297,000 in selected operating reductions, for about $530,000 in recurring personnel and discretionary General Fund reductions.

The personnel savings came from leaving a finance data entry clerk and one police officer position unfunded. Madden said the police reduction is effectively offset by the addition of a sergeant to supervise school resource officers, with the St. Tammany Parish School Board paying 10 months of the position’s annual cost and the city responsible for the remaining two months. Operating reductions included nearly $80,000 in legal fees, $75,000 in planning and development, $50,000 in audit and accounting fees and reductions in spending for the Trailhead, Community Center, advertising, banquets, travel and memberships.

Madden said he and Farno began working on the reductions in January as they sought to produce a structurally balanced operating budget.

“We don’t have the luxury of just sitting here in a council meeting and figuring out what we’re going to cut,” Madden said. “We’ve been working on this since January.”

The proposed budget currently projects recurring General Fund revenue exceeding recurring expenditures by approximately $200,000.

That margin could largely disappear under Lane’s proposed COLA amendment.

“I would like to propose an amendment to add 1.8%,” Lane said, bringing the proposed employee COLA from 1% to 2.8%.

Farno confirmed the proposal would increase General Fund expenses and said it would also affect the city’s Enterprise Fund.

Madden immediately asked Lane where she planned to find the money.

“We can talk about that tomorrow,” Lane responded.

Lane later identified several areas she was considering for possible reductions, including landscaping and planning expenditures.

Without offsetting reductions, however, the roughly $200,000 COLA increase would consume essentially all of the operating margin contained in Madden’s proposed budget. Discon’s additional $15,000 expenditure would then push recurring expenditures beyond recurring revenues, absent other changes.

Discon proposes spending after calling for cuts

Discon’s proposed addition came after several budget hearings in which he has questioned city spending.

During the council’s Aug. 13 hearing, Discon said, “I still think — we’re overspending,” prompting Madden to repeatedly ask him to identify what should be cut. Discon did not identify specific reductions at that meeting, saying the council had additional hearings remaining.

Wednesday, as council members began identifying amendments they planned to bring forward at the final hearing, Discon proposed adding $15,000 for equipment he said could be used to water city trees.

“I’m going to propose $15,000 in the budget for a water truck to water the trees that we’re spending thousands and thousands of dollars on,” Discon said.

LaGrange told Discon the city already has equipment capable of watering trees and said personnel, rather than equipment, is the limiting factor.

“We have equipment,” LaGrange said. “We need the person to do it. It has nothing to do with the equipment.”

“I think once we get it, we can figure that out,” Discon responded.

Discon also renewed an objection to what he believed was a $2 million FEMA reimbursement being counted in the FY2027 budget, saying he would “have an issue with the budget” if the money remained included.

Farno told him it was not.

“There is no FEMA revenue in the fiscal year ’27 budget,” Farno said.

Farno said the disputed $2 million reimbursement was never included as revenue in the FY2027 budget. The unresolved reimbursement remained among anticipated FY2026 revenue and is being removed through year-end adjustments because it was not received during the fiscal year.

Farno said the adjustment still leaves FY2026 with a projected $13.65 million ending General Fund balance — higher than the $13.18 million beginning balance she assumed when preparing the FY2027 budget.

“I still have not over-projected beginning fund balance for fiscal year ’27,” Farno said.

Lane seeks 2.8% COLA

Lane’s proposal would restore the employee COLA to 2.8%, matching the Social Security Administration’s 2026 cost-of-living adjustment.

The administration’s proposed FY2027 budget includes a 1% COLA.

Lane said her amendment would add the remaining 1.8 percentage points, which she and Farno discussed as costing approximately $200,000 in the General Fund.

Lane said she was considering possible reductions elsewhere in the budget to offset the increase, including landscaping and planning expenditures, but did not identify specific cuts Wednesday.

The COLA has been a recurring issue throughout the budget hearings, with Madden defending the administration’s broader compensation package and council members debating whether employees should receive the full 2.8% increase.

Zuckerman previously said he supports the 2.8% COLA but only if the council finds offsetting cuts. “I will absolutely support a 2.8% COLA if we can find budget cuts through the line items to pay for that,” he said during the Aug. 19 hearing.

Lane also questioned what had resulted from the Income Strategies Committee formed following last year’s budget discussions, asking whether the group had examined issues including employee benefits, investing restricted funds and the city’s five-year financial forecast.

Madden pointed to several issues considered by the committee, including a possible tax reallocation, and cited Zuckerman’s proposal establishing a 20% minimum General Fund reserve as one of its significant results. Strong-Thompson noted the committee also worked on improved quarterly financial reporting. Madden said some of the committee’s work was put on hold around April so the short-staffed Finance Department could focus on completing the audit and preparing the FY2027 budget, but said the committee is expected to resume meeting.

Vogeltanz proposes increasing mayoral compensation

Vogeltanz introduced a different spending discussion when he said the council should reconsider how much Mandeville pays its mayor.

He first proposed doubling the mayor’s monthly vehicle allowance from $500 to $1,000, increasing the annual allowance from $6,000 to $12,000.

Vogeltanz said Madden uses his personal vehicle extensively for city business without receiving mileage reimbursement and argued that increasing the allowance could remain less expensive than providing the mayor a city-owned vehicle.

He then said he intends to propose increasing the mayor’s salary, although he had not settled on an amount Wednesday.

The proposed budget would put the mayor’s salary at approximately $122,000 with the 1% COLA, according to Vogeltanz. He floated increasing it to approximately $130,000 while saying his longer-term goal is for the position to pay $150,000 when the next mayoral term begins in 2028.

“This has nothing to do with the mayor [Madden] because he holds the office at the moment,” Vogeltanz said.

Madden proposed no such increase in the mayor’s salary in the FY2027 budget which sits before the council now. In Madden’s budget, as proposed, he would only receive the same 1% COLA that all employees would receive.

Vogeltanz said his concern was the future of the office and ensuring Mandeville could attract qualified candidates in future elections.

“I would really like when we qualify a mayor in 2027 to start the new term in 2028, no matter who it is, I would like to see us at 150 for that position,” Vogeltanz said.

Police Chief Todd Schliem then came forward to support increasing compensation for the office, saying the mayor is approximately the ninth-highest-paid city employee despite bearing responsibility for the entire municipal government.

“This is not about Clay Madden,” Schliem said. “This is about the position of mayor.”

Schliem said he had not discussed the issue with Madden beforehand and argued that compensation should reflect the responsibilities of the position.

The council’s fifth and final FY2027 budget hearing is scheduled for 4 p.m. Thursday, immediately before its regular 6 p.m. meeting where the FY2027 is expected to be voted on.


Related Coverage:

Financial adviser urges City Council to examine employee benefit costs

MANDEVILLE — As the Mandeville City Council considers increasing employee raises in the proposed FY2027 budget, a local financial adviser who had already raised concerns directly with council members urged them Wednesday to look beyond salaries and examine what he described as the compounding…

Continue Reading…


-30-


© 2026 Mandeville Daily. All rights reserved. Republishing permitted with attribution and link to the original article.

"The Prestigious Catahoula Newshound Award. An award I made up, then gave it to myself… five times." — "Wild" Bill Kropog, Editor Emeritus
“The Prestigious Catahoula Newshound Award. An award I made up, then gave it to myself… five times.” — “Wild” Bill Kropog, Editor Emeritus

Financial adviser urges City Council to examine employee benefit costs

Comments come as council considers increasing proposed employee COLA from 1% to 2.8%

Highlights ‘elephant in the room’ employee benefits package

Employees receive Visa card that could eliminate all out-of-pocket, including 100% of deductibles

MANDEVILLE — As the Mandeville City Council considers increasing employee raises in the proposed FY2027 budget, a local financial adviser who had already raised concerns directly with council members urged them Wednesday to look beyond salaries and examine what he described as the compounding cost of the city’s employee benefits package.

Vince Talazac made the comments during the fourth of five City Council budget hearings, telling council members he had emailed them earlier that day as a follow-up to concerns raised at a previous meeting.

His comments came as members prepared amendments expected to be considered during Thursday’s final hearing. Among them, District III Councilwoman Jill Lane said she plans to propose increasing the 1% employee cost-of-living adjustment included in Mayor Clay Madden’s proposed budget to 2.8%.

Mandeville resident and financial adviser Vince Talazac raised concerns about the city’s employee compensation and benefits costs during Wednesday’s fourth FY2027 budget hearing. (⁠The Faces of the Northshore)
Mandeville resident and financial adviser Vince Talazac raised concerns about the city’s employee compensation and benefits costs during Wednesday’s fourth FY2027 budget hearing. (⁠The Faces of the Northshore)

Talazac, who began by praising the council and administration for what he called a “phenomenal job” over the past six years, described employee pay and benefits as the “elephant in the room” and questioned whether the city’s current approach is sustainable.

“So any time we grant a COLA increase, it’s a compounding effect,” Talazac said.

Talazac said every additional dollar in employee pay costs the city approximately another 42 cents through retirement contributions and Social Security where applicable. He also questioned whether the council had sufficiently examined the cost of employee health benefits.

Mandeville’s health insurance plan carries annual deductibles of $7,050 for individual coverage and $14,100 for family coverage, but city employees generally do not have to pay those amounts themselves for eligible in-network care. The city provides employees a “Nonstop Health Visa card” that uses taxpayer money to pay eligible medical expenses and prescriptions.

The Visa card benefit provides up to $8,500 for individual coverage and $17,000 for employee-plus-dependent coverage, enough to cover not only the plan’s deductible but its entire annual out-of-pocket maximum for eligible in-network care.

In practical terms, the taxpayer-funded Visa card could mean an employee pays nothing out-of-pocket except their portion of the premium — $71.35 per month for individual coverage or $203.42 for families — as long as their expenses are covered and in-network.

For employee-only medical coverage, the city pays $1,026.34 of the $1,097.69 monthly premium, while the employee pays $71.35. For family coverage, the city pays $2,926.06 per month while the employee pays $203.42, according to the city’s 2026 benefits guide. That translates to 93.5% of health premiums being funded by the taxpayers.

Mandeville’s 2026 employee health plan provides a city-funded Nonstop Health Visa benefit of up to $8,500 for individual coverage and $17,000 for family coverage for eligible in-network expenses. Those amounts exceed the plan’s stated deductibles of $7,050 and $14,100, respectively. The city also pays about 93.5% of employee health insurance premiums. (Source: City of Mandeville 2026 Benefits Guide. Graphic by Mandeville Daily.)
Mandeville’s 2026 employee health plan provides a city-funded Nonstop Health Visa benefit of up to $8,500 for individual coverage and $17,000 for family coverage for eligible in-network expenses. Those amounts exceed the plan’s stated deductibles of $7,050 and $14,100, respectively. The city also pays about 93.5% of employee health insurance premiums. (Source: City of Mandeville 2026 Benefits Guide. Graphic by Mandeville Daily.)

Talazac also focused on retirement costs. He said Mandeville not only makes its required employer retirement contribution but also pays the contribution that otherwise would be deducted from employee paychecks.

He contrasted Mandeville’s benefits with those offered by neighboring municipalities and argued that the council should consider total compensation rather than evaluating salaries alone.

Talazac said total employee pay and benefits are approaching $18 million, which he calculated at roughly $145,000 in average total compensation across the city’s 125 budgeted positions.

“This is one of, I think, the hardest things I think we have to face,” Talazac said. “It’s unpopular. It’s not gonna be pretty. I don’t know what the answers are.”

Talazac urged the council to undertake a broader examination of employee compensation and benefits rather than continuing to address the issue incrementally.

For additional context, just eight of Mandeville’s 121 city employees live within the city limits, according to figures cited during an earlier budget hearing.

The council’s fifth and final FY2027 budget hearing is scheduled for 4 p.m. Thursday, immediately before its regular 6 p.m. meeting where the FY2027 is expected to be voted on.

-30-


© 2026 Mandeville Daily. All rights reserved. Republishing permitted with attribution and link to the original article.

"The Prestigious Catahoula Newshound Award. An award I made up, then gave it to myself… five times." — "Wild" Bill Kropog, Editor Emeritus
“The Prestigious Catahoula Newshound Award. An award I made up, then gave it to myself… five times.” — “Wild” Bill Kropog, Editor Emeritus

Mayor documents escalating dispute in police report

Report details encounter at local eatery

Filing follows sign dispute and public political criticism

Anonymous mailers and websites later targeted Madden administration

MANDEVILLE — Mayor Clay Madden filed a report with the Mandeville Police Department this month documenting a series of interactions with local businessman Robert “Trey” Berning III that Madden said had “escalated to the point of concern.”

The report recounts a dispute with the city over a sign at Berning’s business, political messages subsequently displayed on the building and an August 2025 restaurant encounter in which Madden told police Berning approached the table where he was meeting with a councilman, sat down uninvited and confronted the mayor over his unsuccessful effort to obtain approval for the sign.

Mandeville Mayor Clay Madden, left, and local businessman Robert “Trey” Berning III. (City of Mandeville; Marquis Who’s Who/24-7 Press Release)
Mandeville Mayor Clay Madden, left, and local businessman Robert “Trey” Berning III. (City of Mandeville; Marquis Who’s Who/24-7 Press Release)

Mandeville Daily learned of Madden’s complaint and subsequently obtained the police report through a public records request. The newspaper then contacted both Madden and Berning for comment.

Berning acknowledged receiving Mandeville Daily’s questions but did not provide responses before publication.

Madden told Mandeville Daily he filed the report after numerous residents and a campaign adviser urged him to create an official record of the events as a precaution should the situation escalate. The police report does not accuse Berning of a crime. The reporting officer specifically noted that Madden was seeking documentation and that the matter was not being reported as a criminal matter for MPD investigation.

A Mandeville Police Department incident report filed by Mayor Clay Madden documents his account of an ongoing dispute with Robert “Trey” Berning III and the events Madden says led him to become concerned. Police noted the matter was not reported as a criminal matter for investigation. (Mandeville Police Department)
A Mandeville Police Department incident report filed by Mayor Clay Madden documents his account of an ongoing dispute with Robert “Trey” Berning III and the events Madden says led him to become concerned. Police noted the matter was not reported as a criminal matter for investigation. (Mandeville Police Department)

Download police report here…

An encounter at Salad Station

According to the police report, Madden was meeting Councilman-at-Large Scott Discon at Salad Station on Aug. 28, 2025, when Berning approached their table and sat down.

Madden told police Berning discussed his difficulties obtaining approval for a sign at his business and blamed the mayor for the denial.

According to Madden’s account in the report, Berning told him that “if I don’t get my sign, I will keep you from being re-elected.”

Madden told Mandeville Daily that he prides himself on being accessible to the public, but said that accessibility “should never be mistaken for vulnerability.”

“This political consultant approached my table uninvited and essentially threatened me with political consequences unless I broke the rules for him,” Madden said. “I will not be pressured, intimidated, or coerced into compromising my responsibilities. And consider this: What if I had simply been sitting there having dinner with my family?”


What if I had simply been sitting there having dinner with my family?

— Mayor Clay Madden


Sign dispute begins with building renovation

The dispute traced back to Berning’s renovation of his commercial building at 633 N. Lotus Drive. City records show Berning received a permit in October 2024 to renovate the building’s front roof and facade, constructing a large raised structure across the front. Five days after the renovation permit was issued, Berning applied to install signage on the new structure.

Planning Director Cara Bartholomew denied the sign permit the same day, concluding that the proposed sign was a roof sign, a type of sign prohibited under the city’s land-use code. Berning disagreed, arguing that the renovation had created a new roof plane and that the proposed sign therefore qualified as a permissible wall sign.

City of Mandeville Planning Department photo shows the renovated commercial building at 633 N. Lotus Drive, including the large facade where Robert “Trey” Berning III sought permission to install signage. The city denied the sign permit, and the Mandeville Zoning Commission later upheld that decision on appeal. (City of Mandeville Planning Department)
City of Mandeville Planning Department photo shows the renovated commercial building at 633 N. Lotus Drive, including the large facade where Robert “Trey” Berning III sought permission to install signage. The city denied the sign permit, and the Mandeville Zoning Commission later upheld that decision on appeal. (City of Mandeville Planning Department)

Berning exercised his right to appeal Bartholomew’s administrative decision to the Mandeville Zoning Commission on Jan. 14, 2025. During the hearing, Berning and an architect supporting his appeal argued that the city was misinterpreting its sign code and pointed to signs on other commercial buildings they believed supported their interpretation. Commissioners were unpersuaded. One described the newly constructed facade as appearing “literally like somebody kinda put a billboard up there,” while another said it looked like “an extension of a permanent billboard sign.”

The commission voted 4-0 to deny Berning’s appeal, leaving Bartholomew’s decision in place. City officials told Berning that the decision was not appealable to the City Council and that his next avenue of appeal was directly to court.

Berning later challenged the decision in 22nd Judicial District Court, but his appeal was unsuccessful. The court dismissed Berning’s challenge with prejudice in May 2025, leaving the city’s decision in place.

The large facade Berning constructed for the proposed signage remains blank today.

Sign dispute turns publicly political

Public criticism of Madden followed the sign dispute. During the 2025 Mardi Gras season, the words “FIRE CLAY MADDEN” were projected across the same large, blank facade where Berning had sought permission to install his business signage. The display is also documented in Madden’s police report as having occurred along the Eve Parade route.

The words “FIRE CLAY MADDEN — SAVE MANDEVILLE” are projected across the large facade of Robert “Trey” Berning III’s N. Lotus Drive building during the 2025 Mardi Gras season. The same facade was at the center of Berning’s unsuccessful appeal of the city’s denial of his sign permit. (Courtesy photo)
The words “FIRE CLAY MADDEN — SAVE MANDEVILLE” are projected across the large facade of Robert “Trey” Berning III’s N. Lotus Drive building during the 2025 Mardi Gras season. The same facade was at the center of Berning’s unsuccessful appeal of the city’s denial of his sign permit. (Courtesy photo)

Berning subsequently shared criticism of the city’s handling of his sign appeal through social media, including professionally produced content published by his digital media company. Among the material was a video using selected portions of the Zoning Commission hearing that criticized commissioners by name and accused Bartholomew of being “vindictive and retaliatory.”

Madden says he could not override sign decision

Although Madden said Berning directed his frustration over the sign dispute toward him, the mayor had no authority to overturn Bartholomew’s decision, grant Berning’s appeal or otherwise approve the sign himself.

State law specifically authorizes municipal zoning regulation and provides for decisions by zoning commissions and other designated land-use authorities, subject ultimately to judicial review.

Mandeville’s own Comprehensive Land Use Regulations similarly place those responsibilities with the city’s Planning and Zoning commissions and planning staff. Commission members are appointed by the City Council — not the mayor — and the Zoning Commission exercises the powers assigned to it under Louisiana law.

Anonymous campaign follows

Months after the Salad Station encounter, an anonymous campaign targeting Madden and his administration began appearing around Mandeville. At least three mailers have been distributed to residents, while two websites — MandevilleWatergate.com and FireClayMadden.com — have criticized Madden over city spending, utility rates and other issues. The materials do not publicly identify their author or sponsor.

This artwork accompanied Mandeville Daily’s Aug. 11 report examining three anonymous mailers and two websites targeting Mayor Clay Madden and his administration. At the time of that reporting, Mandeville Daily had not named or identified anyone suspected of being behind the campaign. (Mandeville Daily)
This artwork accompanied Mandeville Daily’s Aug. 11 report examining three anonymous mailers and two websites targeting Mayor Clay Madden and his administration. At the time of that reporting, Mandeville Daily had not named or identified anyone suspected of being behind the campaign. (Mandeville Daily)

Madden said supporters began examining the websites and presented him with historical domain and IP-address records that he says contributed to his belief that Berning was behind the campaign.

The police report does not accuse Berning of producing the mailers or operating the websites. Madden’s identification of Berning as the person behind the campaign remains an allegation.

-30-


© 2026 Mandeville Daily. All rights reserved. Republishing permitted with attribution and link to the original article.

Council finds nothing to cut in FY2027 operating budget after earlier claim of overspending

Discon, who said last week ‘we’re overspending,’ offers no operating cuts and says budget now ‘looks pretty sufficient’

Civil Service’s 2.8% COLA would consume roughly $200,000 budget cushion

MANDEVILLE — After weeks of warnings about city spending and a pointed challenge from Mayor Clay Madden to identify where Mandeville was overspending, Councilman-at-Large Scott Discon completed his review of the proposed fiscal year 2027 operating budget Wednesday night without identifying a specific expense he would cut.

Discon, who also serves as the council chairman, ultimately joined other council members in praising Madden’s proposed operating budget, saying he found little room for significant reductions.

“I’m looking at the budget right now, and I do agree with everybody that it looks pretty sufficient,” Discon said.

Later, after the council had worked through the operating budget, Discon acknowledged he saw little room for substantial reductions.

“We went through the operational tonight,” Discon said. “I don’t see where we could make any big change. I guess we’d have to look at capital.”

Discon then suggested capital had been the greater area of concern during last year’s budget deliberations — a characterization Councilman-at-Large Jason Zuckerman immediately challenged based on Discon’s own voting record.

“If I remember correctly, last year, capital was where we had more concerns on budget cutting,” Discon said.

Discon questioned on last year’s vote

Zuckerman pointed out that approximately $2.2 million in proposed reductions last year had instead targeted the operating budget — the same budget Discon ultimately voted against — while Discon voted in favor of the capital budget.

“Again, you just mentioned that last year the concern was in the capital budget, but there was $2.2 million in cuts offered to the operating budget, and the operating budget is what you voted against,” Zuckerman said. “You voted for the capital budget.”

Mandeville City Council members review the proposed fiscal year 2027 operating budget during Wednesday night’s budget hearing at City Hall. The council found little support for significant operating cuts after working through the spending plan. (Mandeville Daily)
Mandeville City Council members review the proposed fiscal year 2027 operating budget during Wednesday night’s budget hearing at City Hall. The council found little support for significant operating cuts after working through the spending plan. (Mandeville Daily)

Discon did not dispute Zuckerman’s account, saying instead that he could not recall all of the details of the previous year’s deliberations.

“I can’t remember the specifics of everything that happened a year ago,” Discon said. “It’s been a big year of a lot of work on the council. So without getting into nit-picky, accept my explanation and let’s move forward.”

The exchange followed a notable shift from Discon’s comments during the council’s Aug. 13 budget hearing, when he accused the city of overspending under the proposed FY2027 budget and said expenses should be reduced.

“I still think — we’re overspending,” Discon said at that hearing. “We should be saving some money somewhere.”

Discon argued then that before city officials considered changing how restricted tax revenues could be used or asking voters for greater flexibility, the council should demonstrate that it was serious about “fine-tuning our expenses.”

When Madden pressed Discon to identify where the city was overspending, Discon said council members had not yet conducted their detailed review of the operating budget and he was not prepared to identify specific reductions.

Wednesday night was that review. With no significant operating cuts identified, the search for the savings Discon has advocated now moves to the capital budget, which the council is scheduled to examine at its next budget hearing, scheduled for Aug. 26 at 6 p.m.

Looking for ‘fat’ in ‘clean’ operating budget

And Discon was not alone in finding little to cut from operations.

District II Councilman Kevin Vogeltanz, who proposed approximately $2.2 million in operating-budget reductions last year, called the proposed FY2027 spending plan “a very good budget.”

“There’s not a lot of fat in this budget, at least from the operating side,” Vogeltanz said.

Vogeltanz explored whether an across-the-board 1% reduction could produce additional savings but questioned whether such an arbitrary cut would accomplish anything beyond forcing departments to return to the council later for budget amendments when legitimate expenses arose.

“I don’t know at the moment if I have any proposed cuts to make at all,” he said.

District I Councilwoman Cynthia Strong-Thompson similarly described the proposal as “a very good budget” and “a very clean budget,” saying she saw little reason to “nickel and dime” operating expenses.

Zuckerman called it “a very solid budget” and again emphasized what has become one of the administration’s central claims about the FY2027 proposal: recurring revenues are projected to exceed recurring operating expenses.

“This is the first time since I’ve been on the council we were able to put together a structurally balanced budget,” Zuckerman said. “We’re paying for recurring expenses with recurring revenues.”

Discon also credited the administration for reaching that benchmark.

“This year, yes, you created a balanced budget,” Discon said. “Bravo. I’m proud of you for doing that.”

2.8% COLA would consume operating cushion without cuts

The council’s favorable assessment of the operating budget came immediately after a nearly hourlong joint proceeding with Mandeville’s Civil Service Board over employee compensation.

The Civil Service Board unanimously recommended a 2.8% cost-of-living adjustment for police and non-police employees, compared with the 1% COLA already included in Madden’s proposed budget.

The 2.8% recommendation matches the Social Security Administration’s 2026 cost-of-living adjustment.

Upon taking office in 2020, Madden set out to address what he described as a pay and morale disparity between Mandeville and neighboring municipalities.

In February 2022, the council approved Madden’s sweeping pay-scale overhaul, bringing city employee salaries in line with or above those of comparable municipalities in the region. Since then, the council has granted the Civil Service Board’s requested COLA each year.

Finance Director Jessica Farno said each additional half percentage point costs the General Fund approximately $60,000, including associated personnel costs. Increasing the COLA from 1% to 2.8% would therefore add approximately $216,000 in recurring expenses.

That figure is significant because the proposed General Fund currently contains roughly $200,000 more in recurring revenues than recurring expenses. A 2.8% COLA would likely push the budget as proposed — without any cuts — just beyond the “structurally balanced” mark.

Vogeltanz framed the decision plainly.

“We found a way to save $200,000,” Vogeltanz said. “We’re gonna spend it immediately.”

He emphasized that the council could choose to do so, but said it should recognize the long-term implications of adding recurring personnel expenses.

Zuckerman said during the Civil Service discussion that he could support the 2.8% COLA if the council identified recurring savings elsewhere in the budget to fund the additional expense.

Strong-Thompson appeared more comfortable using the existing operating cushion, noting that recurring revenues would still cover recurring expenses at approximately the amount proposed.

The council did not decide the COLA Wednesday.

Near the end of the budget hearing, Strong-Thompson asked whether the council would settle on the Civil Service Board’s 2.8% recommendation or remain with Madden’s proposed 1%.

Discon deferred the decision.

“We can conclude the meeting and everybody can think about it,” he said.


Related Coverage:

Joint meeting devolves into confusion as members of competing bodies shout over one another

MANDEVILLE — An unusual joint proceeding between the Mandeville City Council and Civil Service Board descended at one point into members talking and shouting over one another Wednesday night, exposing the practical consequences of a meeting arrangement the city attorney had defended hours earlier under Louisiana’s…

Continue Reading…


Discon raises FEMA, sales-tax concerns already addressed in emails

Discon raised two remaining concerns with the operating budget: nearly $2 million in disputed FEMA reimbursement revenue and a projected increase in the amount transferred from a dedicated Special Sales Tax Fund to reimburse the General Fund for eligible Public Works expenses.

The questions were not new. An email exchange between Discon and Finance Director Jessica Farno obtained by Mandeville Daily shows the two had discussed both issues repeatedly before Wednesday’s hearing, with Farno providing detailed written explanations and Discon indicating a week earlier that he understood them.

The exchange was extensive. Between July 22 and the afternoon of Wednesday’s hearing, Discon and Farno exchanged at least nine substantive emails concerning the budget questions, including four written responses from Farno explaining the accounting and reimbursement issues in detail. Her final response Wednesday afternoon alone ran roughly 800 words and included supporting documentation.

Graphic representing the highlights of a lengthy email exchange concerning the FY2027 proposed budget between Councilman-at-Large Scott Discon and Finance Director Jessica Farno. (Mandeville Daily)
Graphic representing the highlights of a lengthy email exchange concerning the FY2027 proposed budget between Councilman-at-Large Scott Discon and Finance Director Jessica Farno. (Mandeville Daily)

On Aug. 12, Farno explained that the city was awaiting a decision on its appeal involving $1.998 million in disputed Hurricane Ida reimbursement revenue. She said the money had already been anticipated in FY2026 and, if a decision was not received before the fiscal year ended Aug. 31, the anticipated revenue would move into FY2027.

Discon responded: “And I understand the FEMA reimbursement.”

Six days later, however, Discon raised the issue again in an Aug. 18 email, this time questioning whether the city should anticipate receiving the money at all. Because FEMA had previously denied the amount and the matter was in arbitration, Discon wrote, “there is a high probability that we will not ever get this amount. Why count it if you don’t have it?”

Farno responded at 2:59 p.m. Wednesday, hours before the budget hearing, copying Madden and the remainder of the council. She disputed Discon’s assessment, saying she was unaware of any information about the city’s pending appeal supporting the conclusion that there was a high probability it would receive nothing.

“I do not believe it would be appropriate to remove the anticipated reimbursement from the forecast solely by assuming an unfavorable outcome before the appeal/arbitration process has been completed,” Farno wrote.

Discon nevertheless raised the concern again during Wednesday night’s hearing.

“If you don’t have it, don’t count it,” Discon said, warning that the city could find itself “$2 million in the hole” if the reimbursement never materializes.

The email exchange shows a similar back-and-forth over Discon’s second concern, involving a projected increase in the transfer from the Special Sales Tax Fund to the General Fund for eligible Public Works expenses.

Discon had questioned the roughly 90% estimate as early as July 22. Farno explained Aug. 10 that the percentage was a budgetary estimate of eligible expenses, not a predetermined reimbursement rate. At year-end, she said, Finance reviews actual expenditures and transfers only those costs that qualify under the sales tax dedication.

Discon sought additional information Aug. 11, and Farno provided another detailed explanation the following day. Discon then summarized his understanding that the budget contained an estimate and that the transfer would ultimately be adjusted to actual eligible expenditures at the end of the fiscal year.

“That’s the gist of it!” Farno replied.

Discon returned to the issue Aug. 18, asking for the actual FY2025 expenditures and questioning whether the FY2027 estimate was too high because of its substantial increase over previous years.

Farno’s Wednesday afternoon response included a retrospective analysis of FY2025. Although the city transferred about $2.26 million that year — approximately 66.2% of total General Fund Public Works expenditures — Finance subsequently identified approximately $2.34 million in eligible expenses using what Farno described as a deliberately conservative review. The analysis did not examine every potentially eligible account because Finance had already identified more eligible expenses than the city actually transferred.

Farno said Finance has since refined its process to more completely identify expenses legally eligible for payment from dedicated funds. She said the higher FY2027 estimate partly reflects repeated council requests that the city make fuller use of restricted revenues for legally eligible expenses rather than unnecessarily relying on the General Fund.

“This change was not made in a vacuum,” Farno wrote to Discon. “You have raised that concern yourself on multiple occasions.”

When Discon raised both matters again during Wednesday night’s hearing, Farno made a point of putting their previous exchanges on the public record.

“Both of those items have been looked at and were explained in extensive detail in my email response to you, as well as in previous meetings with the council,” Farno said. She offered to read the email aloud if Discon still needed an explanation.

Discon asked her instead to paraphrase it.

Council considers additions instead

The few concrete changes discussed during the operating review were additions or reallocations rather than cuts.

Strong-Thompson proposed providing $10,000 each to the Children’s Advocacy Center/Hope House and Youth Service Bureau.

Planning Director Cara Bartholomew subsequently identified approximately $43,000 remaining in the Comprehensive Plan budget that she said was no longer needed because the work had been completed, potentially providing a source for the proposed $20,000 without increasing overall operating expenditures.

Madden also suggested considering $5,000 for the organization responsible for the city’s Veterans Day activities.

The council has not yet adopted the FY2027 budget.

-30-


© 2026 Mandeville Daily. All rights reserved. Republishing permitted with attribution and link to the original article.

"The Prestigious Catahoula Newshound Award. An award I made up, then gave it to myself… five times." — "Wild" Bill Kropog, Editor Emeritus
“The Prestigious Catahoula Newshound Award. An award I made up, then gave it to myself… five times.” — “Wild” Bill Kropog, Editor Emeritus

Joint meeting devolves into confusion as members of competing bodies shout over one another

City attorney said notice complied with Open Meetings Law ‘reasonable specificity’ clause

Zuckerman repeatedly questions what meeting is underway and who is presiding: ‘I’m not sure how the public was aware of that’

MANDEVILLE — An unusual joint proceeding between the Mandeville City Council and Civil Service Board descended at one point into members talking and shouting over one another Wednesday night, exposing the practical consequences of a meeting arrangement the city attorney had defended hours earlier under Louisiana’s Open Meetings Law.

The council’s notice made no mention of a joint Civil Service Board meeting or a cost-of-living adjustment for city employees, although the online version of the agenda had the words “Civil Service” inserted only into the title the day before the meeting.

The online version of the Aug. 19 budget hearing was updated to include the words 'civil service' into the title, but Louisiana Open Meetings Law requires agenda items to include 'reasonable specificity.' (Mandeville Daily)
The online version of the Aug. 19 budget hearing was updated to include the words ‘civil service’ into the title, but Louisiana Open Meetings Law requires agenda items to include ‘reasonable specificity.’ (Mandeville Daily)

The Civil Service Board separately advertised a COLA meeting for the same time and location, describing it as running “concurrently” with the council’s budget hearing. That notice was posted Aug. 14.

But what occurred Wednesday was not simply two public bodies conducting separate meetings at the same time.

The Municipal Police Employees’ Civil Service Board and Municipal Employees’ Civil Service Board, which meet as Mandeville’s combined Civil Service Board, were formally called to order during the council hearing. Members of both bodies then deliberated together for nearly an hour over employee compensation before the Civil Service Board voted unanimously to recommend a 2.8% COLA and adjourned, allowing the council to resume its budget hearing.

Civil Service Board Chairman Brian Burke described the unusual structure from the dais as “a civil service board meeting within a city council meeting.”

The arrangement prompted Zuckerman to twice interrupt the proceeding with points of order questioning which public body was actually meeting and who had authority to preside.


Related Coverage:

Council finds nothing to cut in FY2027 operating budget after earlier claim of overspending

MANDEVILLE — After weeks of warnings about city spending and a pointed challenge from Mayor Clay Madden to identify where Mandeville was overspending, Councilman-at-Large Scott Discon completed his review of the proposed fiscal year 2027 operating budget Wednesday night without identifying a specific expense…

Continue Reading…


“Are we in the council meeting right now? Are we turning this over to the civil service board to have their meeting? How is this working?” Zuckerman asked.

Later, after discussion had moved among members of both bodies, he raised the issue again.

“Who is — what meeting are we in, and who is chairing this meeting at the moment?” Zuckerman asked.

The distinction became more than procedural as the COLA debate grew contentious. Burke and Vogeltanz and District I Councilwoman Cynthia Strong-Thompson began talking over one another during an increasingly heated exchange, with multiple officials attempting to control the discussion.

Members of the Mandeville City Council and Civil Service Board meet together Wednesday during the council’s fiscal year 2027 budget hearing. The unusual proceeding, described by Civil Service Board Chairman Brian Burke as “a civil service board meeting within a city council meeting,” led to confusion over which body was presiding as members debated a proposed cost-of-living adjustment for city employees. (Mandeville Daily)
Members of the Mandeville City Council and Civil Service Board meet together Wednesday during the council’s fiscal year 2027 budget hearing. The unusual proceeding, described by Civil Service Board Chairman Brian Burke as “a civil service board meeting within a city council meeting,” led to confusion over which body was presiding as members debated a proposed cost-of-living adjustment for city employees. (Mandeville Daily)

As the discussion grew increasingly contentious, Burke and District II Councilman Kevin Vogeltanz repeatedly talked and at times shouted over one another, with District I Councilwoman Cynthia Strong-Thompson also attempting to interject. Council-at-Large Scott Discon, who also currently serves as council chairman, initially made no effort to restore order as the competing voices continued, intervening only after Councilman-at-Large Jason Zuckerman raised another point of order questioning which meeting was underway and who was presiding.

Discon, who had previously told Zuckerman that he was chairing the meeting, eventually intervened.

“I’m gonna take over right now,” Discon said. “Sorry about that. I will take over now.”

City attorney had defended arrangement hours earlier

The confusion unfolded hours after City Attorney Elizabeth Sconzert defended the arrangement under Louisiana’s Open Meetings Law, saying the council’s advertised agenda item — “Discussion of the FY 2026-2027 Budget” — was sufficiently specific to encompass a COLA discussion with the separately noticed Civil Service Board.

“The Open Meetings Law does not require that the Council notice separately label the meeting as a ‘joint meeting’ merely because the separately noticed Civil Service Boards will be present for, and participate in, the COLA discussion,” Sconzert wrote.

The Civil Service Board’s separate notice specifically identified the COLA and said its meeting would run concurrently with the council budget hearing. The council’s original Aug. 6 notice made no mention of the Civil Service Board, a joint meeting or the COLA.

For full context, the council’s online notice was modified Tuesday, Aug. 18, to add “CIVIL SERVICE” to its title. Its sole item of new business remained “Discussion of the FY 2026-2027 Budget,” however, and the document continued to display its original Aug. 6 notice date.

Wednesday’s proceeding ultimately placed both public bodies in session simultaneously, with their members deliberating together before the Civil Service Board voted on its COLA recommendation and adjourned. Zuckerman maintained during the meeting that the council’s notice did not adequately inform the public that such a joint proceeding would occur.

‘I’m not sure how the public was aware of that’

Zuckerman formally objected during the meeting, saying he did not believe it had been properly advertised.

“If I’m a six-year council member and I had no idea based on the agendas or the discussions or when we scheduled this meeting that this was gonna be a joint meeting tonight, I’m not sure how the public was aware of that,” Zuckerman said.

Zuckerman said his understanding when the budget hearings were originally scheduled was that officials knew the Civil Service Board also had a meeting Wednesday night and contemplated allowing it to use a conference room while the council conducted its budget hearing.

“My understanding was they were gonna be in the conference room,” he said.

The council and Civil Service Board had previously agreed to meet again to discuss the COLA after council members had an opportunity to review Mayor Clay Madden’s proposed budget. But the council had not yet reviewed the operating budget — where the COLA would be funded — before Wednesday night’s joint meeting, one reason Zuckerman said he was confused about why the two bodies were meeting together that night.

Wednesday’s meeting ultimately accomplished that purpose, but it was not identified as a joint meeting on the council agenda.

The Civil Service Board unanimously recommended a 2.8% COLA before adjourning its meeting. The council took no action on the recommendation and continued with its operating-budget review.

-30-


© 2026 Mandeville Daily. All rights reserved. Republishing permitted with attribution and link to the original article.

"The Prestigious Catahoula Newshound Award. An award I made up, then gave it to myself… five times." — "Wild" Bill Kropog, Editor Emeritus
“The Prestigious Catahoula Newshound Award. An award I made up, then gave it to myself… five times.” — “Wild” Bill Kropog, Editor Emeritus

Civil Service Board to join council budget hearing despite council notice making no mention of joint meeting

Zuckerman says he was not informed of joint meeting, has concern about Open Meetings law

City attorney responds after publication, says meeting arrangement complies with state law

MANDEVILLE — Mandeville’s Civil Service Board will meet with the City Council during Wednesday night’s budget hearing to discuss and vote on a cost-of-living adjustment for city employees, despite the City Council’s public meeting notice making no mention of the board, a joint meeting or the COLA.

The board — formally the Municipal Police Employees’ Civil Service Board and Municipal Employees’ Civil Service Board, which meet as a combined body — was separately advertised to meet at the same time and location as the council.

The unusual arrangement emerged Wednesday morning after Mandeville Daily sought clarification of separate public notices scheduling both bodies to meet at 6 p.m. Wednesday at City Hall.

The City Council’s notice, dated Aug. 6, advertises a budget hearing with a single item of new business: “Discussion of the FY 2026-2027 Budget.”

The Mandeville City Council’s budget hearing notice dated Aug. 6 and the Municipal Police Employees’ Civil Service Board and Municipal Employees’ Civil Service Board meeting notice dated Aug. 14. (City of Mandeville)
The Mandeville City Council’s budget hearing notice dated Aug. 6 and the Municipal Police Employees’ Civil Service Board and Municipal Employees’ Civil Service Board meeting notice dated Aug. 14. (City of Mandeville)

A Civil Service Board notice dated Aug. 14 schedules the board to meet at the identical time and location to consider a “Cost-of-living adjustment for the Police and Non-Police employees of the City of Mandeville for FY26-27.”

Rather than describing the proceeding as a joint meeting, however, the Civil Service Board notice says in its heading that the meeting will be “RUNNING CONCURRENTLY WITH THE CITY COUNCIL’S FY27 BUDGET HEARING.”

The council’s notice contains no corresponding reference to the Civil Service Board meeting.

Asked Wednesday morning whether the proceedings were a joint meeting and whether the bodies would meet in separate rooms, Council Clerk Alicia Watts confirmed that the Civil Service Board will instead join the council for a portion of its budget hearing.

“It is, the Civil Service Board will be present with the Council and available for discussion of the COLA, then they will be voting on the rate they will recommend to Council, then their portion of the meeting will adjourn and it will return to the Council,” Watts wrote.

Mandeville Daily followed up Wednesday morning asking why the proceeding was not advertised as a joint meeting, who called or arranged for the Civil Service Board to participate in the council’s previously advertised budget hearing and who informed Watts of the arrangement.

No response to those questions had been received as of publication.


UPDATE: City attorney says arrangement complies with Open Meetings Law

City Attorney Elizabeth Sconzert responded after publication Wednesday, saying the arrangement complies with Louisiana’s Open Meetings Law and that the council was not required to advertise the proceeding as a joint meeting.

Sconzert said the council’s posted agenda item, “Discussion of the FY 2026-2027 Budget,” satisfies the law’s requirement that agenda items be described with reasonable specificity because the COLA and the Civil Service Board’s recommendation are components of the operating budget discussion.

“A COLA and the Civil Service Boards’ recommendations concerning it are components of the FY 2026–27 operating budget discussion,” Sconzert wrote. “The Open Meetings Law does not require that the Council notice separately label the meeting as a ‘joint meeting’ merely because the separately noticed Civil Service Boards will be present for, and participate in, the COLA discussion.”

Sconzert said the council will first call its budget hearing to order and begin its regular proceedings. When discussion reaches the COLA, the Civil Service Board will separately be called to order and participate in the discussion.

The board will then vote on the COLA rate or rates it will recommend to the council and adjourn its portion of the proceeding. The council will remain in session and continue discussing the remainder of the budget. The council is not scheduled to vote on the COLA or any other budget matter Wednesday.

Sconzert cited Maxwell v. Board of Elementary and Secondary Education in arguing that Louisiana courts evaluate agenda descriptions in context and do not require exhaustive detail when the public has reasonable notice of the subject to be discussed.

She also cited Rushing v. Southeastern Louisiana University in addressing the Open Meetings Law provision allowing actions taken in violation of the law to be voided. Because the council will take no final action Wednesday, Sconzert said there would be no council action from the hearing to set aside.

Sconzert did not identify who arranged for the Civil Service Board to join the previously scheduled council budget hearing or address why the arrangement was not disclosed more clearly on the council’s notice as a matter of public convenience, questions Mandeville Daily had also raised in its follow-up.


When reached for comment, Councilman-at-Large Jason Zuckerman told Mandeville Daily he was not informed that Wednesday night’s budget hearing was intended to be a joint meeting with the Civil Service Board and raised concerns about whether the arrangement complies with Louisiana’s Open Meetings Law.

The arrangement closely resembles the follow-up joint meeting that the council and Civil Service Board agreed last month should occur after council members had an opportunity to review Mayor Clay Madden’s proposed fiscal year 2027 budget.

At a July 1 joint meeting, Civil Service Board Chairman Brian Burke made the board’s customary motion to recommend a COLA, proposing a 2.8% increase matching the increase announced by the Social Security Administration. Madden’s proposed budget, which had been released to council members less than 24 hours earlier, includes funding for a 1% COLA.

Council members declined to commit to a recurring salary increase before conducting their formal budget review.

Zuckerman suggested reconvening after the council had an opportunity to examine the proposed budget and determine the financial effect of a COLA. Other council members similarly expressed concerns about making a compensation decision before reviewing the city’s overall spending plan.

Rather than vote on Burke’s 2.8% recommendation, the Civil Service Board tabled the matter. Officials agreed to schedule another joint meeting after the council’s budget hearings were underway.

Although the council has since held two budget hearings, on Aug. 12 and 13, council members have not yet discussed what COLA, if any, they would support. Zuckerman said the operating budget — including the spending that would fund employee compensation — was expected to be discussed at Wednesday night’s hearing.

Wednesday’s proceeding appears to serve as the contemplated follow-up joint meeting, but it was not advertised as such on the City Council’s notice. Council Chairman Scott Discon is responsible for setting the council’s agendas, yet the Aug. 6 notice makes no mention of the Civil Service Board, a joint meeting or the COLA. Discon was copied on Mandeville Daily’s correspondence with Watts seeking clarification Wednesday morning but had not responded as of publication. It remained unclear who arranged for the Civil Service Board to join the previously scheduled council budget hearing.

It remained unclear who arranged for the Civil Service Board to join the previously scheduled council budget hearing.

Louisiana’s Open Meetings Law requires public bodies to provide advance notice of their meetings, including the date, time, place and agenda. The law also requires agenda items to be separately listed and described with reasonable specificity.

The Civil Service Board’s notice identifies both the COLA and the council budget hearing. The City Council’s notice, however, tells members of the public only that the council will hold a hearing for “Discussion of the FY 2026-2027 Budget.” It does not state that the Civil Service Board will convene with the council during the hearing or that the two bodies will jointly discuss employee compensation.

Wednesday’s meeting is scheduled to begin at 6 p.m. at Mandeville City Hall.

-30-


© 2026 Mandeville Daily. All rights reserved. Republishing permitted with attribution and link to the original article.

"The Prestigious Catahoula Newshound Award. An award I made up, then gave it to myself… five times." — "Wild" Bill Kropog, Editor Emeritus
“The Prestigious Catahoula Newshound Award. An award I made up, then gave it to myself… five times.” — “Wild” Bill Kropog, Editor Emeritus

Council adopts expanded public comment rules after 45-minute debate

Resolution increases speaking time to four minutes, allows comments on ordinance introductions and leaves placement of general public comment to council chair

Lengthy discussion centers on what residents should be permitted to discuss before council takes no action

MANDEVILLE — A City Council effort to give residents more opportunities to speak turned into a roughly 45-minute debate Thursday over when they should speak, what they should be allowed to discuss and how long they should be permitted to continue.

The council ultimately adopted Resolution 26-32, replacing its 2024 meeting rules and expanding the standard public-comment period from three minutes to four. The new rules also expressly allow residents to comment on ordinance introductions during the council’s general public-comment period, reversing an interpretation the council upheld in July that prohibited such comments.

The resolution passed after a lengthy discussion that at times ranged well beyond its two principal changes, touching on presentations, questions versus debate, the location of public comment on the agenda, written comments, donated speaking time and even District II Councilman Kevin Vogeltanz’s high school debate career.

Louisiana’s Open Meetings Law requires public bodies such as the City Council to provide an opportunity for public comment before taking action on an agenda item that will be put to a vote. The law also allows governing bodies to adopt “reasonable rules and restrictions” governing that comment period.

The council’s general public-comment period goes further, providing residents an opportunity to raise matters on which the council is not scheduled to vote.

That distinction became a recurring point during Thursday’s debate.

Councilman-at-Large Jason Zuckerman said the purpose of separating general public comment from comment on voting items was largely practical: Residents can raise other matters during general public comment and then speak on voting items when those items come before the council.

“It just keeps the meeting moving so that people aren’t coming up twice and saying the same thing and filibustering, that sort of thing,” Zuckerman said.

But Zuckerman said residents otherwise should have broad latitude during the general comment period.

“You can speak about anything you want,” he said. “You can talk about a recipe you like. It doesn’t matter to me.”

Resolution reverses July ruling

The rules rewrite grew out of a dispute at the council’s July 9 meeting, when Councilman-at-Large Scott Discon, the council’s current chairman, ruled that residents could not use general public comment to discuss an ordinance being introduced that evening because the ordinance appeared on the agenda.

Vogeltanz challenged the ruling, arguing that the existing restriction on discussing agenda items was intended to prevent residents from speaking twice on matters already receiving their own public-comment period — not to prohibit discussion of ordinance introductions, which receive no vote at the meeting where they are introduced.

The council upheld Discon’s ruling 3-2, with Vogeltanz and Zuckerman voting to overturn it.

Discon subsequently sponsored Resolution 26-32 to reverse that interpretation.

“I decided after the meeting that I felt like we should repeal that and fix it,” Discon said Thursday. “Because I do think the public has a right to speak.”

Discon said residents have told him they do not believe their voices are being heard and characterized the change as an effort toward greater transparency.

The resolution specifically adds ordinance introductions to the subjects residents may discuss during general public comment, meaning a resident may now publicly address a proposed ordinance when it first appears before the council rather than waiting until the meeting at which it comes up for a vote.

Residents will still receive another opportunity to comment before the council votes, as required by state law.

Council debates where to draw the line

District I Councilwoman Cynthia Strong-Thompson questioned whether allowing discussion of ordinance introductions blurred the distinction between general public comment and the separate comment periods attached to voting items.

Her understanding of general public comment, she said, was that it provided an opportunity to raise matters that otherwise would not come before the council that evening.

Strong-Thompson also noted that ordinances can change substantially between introduction and final consideration.

District III Councilwoman Jill Lane raised a similar concern, particularly for ordinances that subsequently go before the Planning and Zoning Commission. Comments made to the council when an ordinance is introduced, she said, might not necessarily follow the proposal through the rest of the review process.

At the same time, Lane said hearing those comments earlier could provide council members and planning commissioners useful information about public sentiment before they begin their deliberations.

Vogeltanz took the broadest view.

“I am what I like to describe myself as a public comment maximalist,” he said. “If I thought I had the votes, I would let people talk for 10 minutes at a time, because why not?”

Vogeltanz said relatively few residents attend council meetings or contact council members and argued that those who make the effort to appear personally can have a significant influence on elected officials.

“When you actually show up to these meetings and you take the time to come to the podium and talk, you have, like, amazing impact on how we think about everything, because so few people will do that,” he said.

Mayor Clay Madden, who previously served eight years on the council, including four as chairman, suggested drawing a distinction between residents asking questions and engaging in debate over matters that are not scheduled for action.

If a resident wants clarification about an ordinance being introduced or a presentation made to the council, Madden said, the chairman should allow the question. But if the council is not voting on the matter, Madden said a chairman could remind speakers that the debate will occur at a later meeting.

City Attorney Elizabeth Sconzert agreed that questions can be appropriate but cautioned against allowing discussions to expand beyond what was advertised on the meeting agenda.

“The bigger concern about those debates and lengthier discussions is that you get outside of what was advertised on the agenda,” Sconzert said, adding that the council should avoid straying into territory that could create an Open Meetings Law problem.

Four minutes becomes the new standard

There was considerably less disagreement over increasing the normal speaking limit.

Discon proposed moving from three minutes to four, saying residents frequently need additional time and council chairmen routinely grant it anyway.

“What’s a minute?” Discon said. “I think a minute’s important, but it’s for the public.”

Zuckerman supported the increase but noted that his research showed three minutes is more common among other public bodies.

Strong-Thompson likewise supported four minutes, saying speakers frequently need nearly another minute under the existing rules.

The discussion became more complicated when council members turned to a provision allowing speakers to receive unused time from other residents.

The previous rules capped a person’s total speaking time at nine minutes. Vogeltanz proposed increasing that limit to 12 minutes to correspond with the new four-minute individual limit.

Strong-Thompson objected, warning that extended speaking periods can turn meetings into “circuses” featuring repetitive or circular arguments. Zuckerman agreed, saying eight minutes was already a substantial amount of time.

Vogeltanz’s 12-minute proposal failed.

The council instead approved an eight-minute maximum, effectively allowing a speaker to use one other person’s donated four-minute period.

The council also approved a Vogeltanz amendment removing language specifying that general public comment occur “at the beginning of the meeting.” The final language instead refers simply to comments made “during the public comment period,” preserving the chairman’s authority to determine where that period appears on an agenda.

Sconzert told council members that much of what they were discussing could already be handled through the chairman’s authority over the agenda.

“I don’t think you necessarily need a resolution for that,” she said.

After the amendments were settled, the council approved Resolution 26-32.

The result is a broader public-comment policy than the one in effect before Thursday: Residents receive four minutes instead of three, may use general public comment to address ordinance introductions even though no vote is scheduled, and can receive donated time from another speaker for a maximum of eight minutes.

The resolution also resolves the dispute that prompted the rewrite in the first place.

A resident who wants to speak about an ordinance when it is introduced can now do so.

After approximately 45 minutes spent determining how that should work, the council made it official.

-30-


© 2026 Mandeville Daily. All rights reserved. Republishing permitted with attribution and link to the original article.

"The Prestigious Catahoula Newshound Award. An award I made up, then gave it to myself… five times." — "Wild" Bill Kropog, Editor Emeritus
“The Prestigious Catahoula Newshound Award. An award I made up, then gave it to myself… five times.” — “Wild” Bill Kropog, Editor Emeritus

Budget hearing erupts over spending claims as councilman questions millions accumulating in restricted funds

Madden presses Discon to back up claim city is overspending in FY2027 budget; Discon balks

Zuckerman asks, ‘What should those fund balances be?’ as projections show restricted funds could grow to $45 million in five years despite regular spending

MANDEVILLE — What began Thursday evening as the second in a series of largely technical hearings on Mandeville’s proposed FY2027 budget ended in a heated confrontation over whether the city is spending too much — and opened a potentially much larger debate over whether taxpayers should continue pouring money into restricted funds that could accumulate an estimated $45 million over the next five years.

The Aug. 13 hearing — the second for FY2027 — produced two distinct financial debates that eventually collided: Councilman-at-Large Scott Discon’s assertion that the city is overspending despite the administration presenting its first structurally balanced budget in years, and Councilman-at-Large Jason Zuckerman’s insistence that the city determine how much money it actually needs to retain in two rapidly growing restricted sales-tax funds.


Budget Hearing #1: FY2027 budget hearings open with first structurally balanced operating budget in years


Zuckerman asks, how much is enough in restricted funds?

The latter question, Zuckerman argued, is essentially the same one the council recently answered for the General Fund.

After months of debate, the council this summer established a 20% minimum General Fund reserve and separately adopted a 30% to 40% target range. Discon cast the lone dissenting vote on both measures.

Zuckerman said Thursday that the city now needs to ask the same fundamental question about its Street Construction Fund and Special Sales Tax Fund:

How much is enough?

The issue arose as Finance Director Jessica Farno reviewed how Mandeville’s 2.5% local sales tax is divided and presented historical growth in several city funds.

From 2020 to 2025, the Street Construction Fund increased by nearly $6 million despite almost $10 million in capital expenditures. The District 3 Special Sales Tax Fund grew by approximately $10.7 million despite $4.6 million in capital spending, while the Special Sales Tax Fund increased approximately $1.5 million despite $14.3 million in expenditures. Over the same period, the General Fund declined approximately $8.4 million while absorbing $13.2 million in capital outlay.


Now, I think we’re wasting everybody else’s time by y’all wanting to get into a one-on-one between me and the mayor, and now you got Zuckerman coming after me.

— Councilman-at-Large Scott Discon


Zuckerman pushed for those historical trends to be projected forward, arguing that the city cannot examine a five-year projection showing pressure on the General Fund without simultaneously examining how much money could accumulate elsewhere.

Based on the preliminary projection discussed Thursday, the Street Construction Fund and Special Sales Tax Fund could together reach approximately $45 million in five years.

Zuckerman repeatedly emphasized that he was excluding the District 3 Special Sales Tax Fund from that figure because Mandeville does not control the dedication of those parish-generated revenues.

“If we’re gonna talk about that, we also gotta be talking about over those next five years, we’re gonna grow those restricted funds,” Zuckerman said. “If we keep doing the same thing that we’ve been doing, simply, the same level of spending and the same revenue dedicated to those pockets, while we’re reducing the General Fund, we’re growing those restricted funds.”

The discussion is particularly timely because the authorization for a 1% sales tax approved in 1986 expires Dec. 31, 2029. Half of that tax may be used for any lawful governmental purpose, while the other half is dedicated to water, sewer, streets, drainage and flood protection.

A separate half-cent tax approved in 2001 and dedicated to streets, sidewalks, bike paths, existing bridges and roadside drainage was renewed by voters in 2021 and runs through July 1, 2031.

Zuckerman said the approaching 2029 expiration gives the city an opportunity to reconsider whether allocations established decades ago still reflect its needs.

“We can either, A, go back to the voters and say, ‘Let’s keep putting money in this fund. Let’s keep taxing you, and let’s watch these fund balances grow, and we can’t spend it,’ or we can put it on the ballot and we can say, ‘Let us spend it differently because things are different than they were 25 years ago,’” Zuckerman said.

Mandeville City Council members review financial projections Thursday during the second hearing on the city’s proposed FY2027 budget. The meeting ended with a contentious exchange over city spending and questions about millions of dollars accumulating in restricted funds. (Mandeville Daily)
Mandeville City Council members review financial projections Thursday during the second hearing on the city’s proposed FY2027 budget. The meeting ended with a contentious exchange over city spending and questions about millions of dollars accumulating in restricted funds. (Mandeville Daily)

There is another option, he added: Let the tax expire.

“That’s not the purpose of government, to keep collecting taxpayers’ money to grow a huge balance that you’re not gonna spend,” Zuckerman said. “I’d rather reduce taxes.”

District III Councilwoman Jill Lane responded by focusing largely on the District 3 Special Sales Tax Fund, despite Zuckerman having specifically excluded that fund from the balances he was questioning. She warned that emphasizing growing balances could make voters reluctant to renew taxes and noted that District 3 revenue is dedicated to costly road and drainage projects.

Discon had repeatedly pushed back at previous meetings on Zuckerman’s suggestion that the city consider asking voters to rededicate some restricted funds. Lane now appeared to add another skeptical voice to that discussion.

“And if as we continue to say stuff like, ‘We’re just, this fund is growing and growing and growing,’” Lane said. “Well, the voters could be like, ‘Well, then we don’t need it anymore.’”

Lane suggested the city instead look for additional eligible uses for District 3 money, including expenses currently paid from the General Fund. She asked, for example, whether some police salaries could potentially qualify based on where officers work.

Public Works Director Keith LaGrange added that future annexation of portions of the city’s growth management area could bring infrastructure with it that Mandeville would have to maintain. He cited an earlier examination of taking over a street that would have required several million dollars to bring to city standards.

“Maybe I didn’t make my point very clearly,” Zuckerman said later. “When I talked about the growth in those restricted funds, I specifically was not talking about the District 3 sales tax fund.”

Zuckerman also told Mandeville Daily that he believes the concern over future street liabilities overstates the city’s circumstances.

Annexations into Mandeville are relatively rare, he said, while many of the city’s major thoroughfares are maintained or funded at the state or parish level. That leaves the city primarily responsible for neighborhood streets, where Mandeville already has an ongoing program of maintenance and capital improvements.

His larger point, Zuckerman said, is that the projection already assumes the city continues spending on streets at approximately the rate it has historically — yet the restricted balances still grow to approximately $45 million.

Finance Director Jessica Farno’s spreadsheet projected five-year growth in several restricted city funds based on their growth rates from 2020 to 2025. Councilman Jason Zuckerman focused on the Street Construction and Special Sales Tax funds, which the projection showed growing to a combined approximately $46 million, while excluding the separately restricted District 3 fund from his argument. (Mandeville Daily)
Finance Director Jessica Farno’s spreadsheet projected five-year growth in several restricted city funds based on their growth rates from 2020 to 2025. Councilman Jason Zuckerman focused on the Street Construction and Special Sales Tax funds, which the projection showed growing to a combined approximately $46 million, while excluding the separately restricted District 3 fund from his argument. (Mandeville Daily)

And if some council members are not willing to consider changing the dedications, Zuckerman said, he at least wants them to confront what the projections are showing.

During Thursday’s hearing, Zuckerman said he was not arguing that the city necessarily has too much money in either fund today. Rather, he wants the council to establish what an appropriate reserve actually is instead of allowing the balance to grow indefinitely simply because the tax dedication already exists.

“What should those fund balances be moving forward?” Zuckerman asked. “I’m not comfortable with we made a decision 25 years ago or 20 years ago to put this much every year into a fund, and 20 years later we just say we can never, ever, ever, ever adjust that or relook at it.”


I’m just asking what should those balances be in five years? And I don’t understand why we can’t talk about that.

— Councilman-at-Large Jason Zuckerman


Lane’s warning that the council calling attention to the growing restricted-fund balances could jeopardize the chances of voter renewal drew a pointed response from Zuckerman, who questioned why publicly discussing how large those funds are becoming was considered off limits by some on the council.

“I’m just asking what should those balances be in five years? And I don’t understand why we can’t talk about that,” Zuckerman said.

“Because we’re collecting tax money, and we’re projecting right there [on presentation screens in the council chambers] that we’re gonna be sitting on that tax money and not spending it.”

Spending accusation sparks heated exchange

The philosophical debate over restricted funds soon gave way to a considerably more contentious exchange over the budget immediately before the council.

Discon said some residents believe the city is overspending and argued that before officials discuss reallocating dedicated tax revenue, the city should demonstrate that it is serious about controlling expenses.

“We’re overspending,” Discon said. “We should be saving some money somewhere.”

Discon also expressed disbelief in the administration’s five-year General Fund forecast.

“I looked at it last night when I got in bed. I was like, ‘God, this is the most beautiful five-year forecast,’” Discon said. “It just looks too unbelievable to be real.”

Mayor Clay Madden challenged him directly.

Madden noted that the administration has presented a structurally balanced FY2027 operating budget, with recurring revenues exceeding recurring expenses by approximately $200,000. He said he, Farno and department directors had gone through the spending plan “with a fine-tooth comb” to reduce expenses before it reached the council.

If Discon believed the city was still overspending, Madden said, he wanted him to identify where.

“I need from you, Councilman Discon, the areas that you feel like we’re overspending. … Not from a text message, not from the people you’re gonna go talk to between the meetings.”

Discon initially characterized his assertion as a general statement and pointed to his opposition to the previous year’s budget.

Madden continued pressing.

“I’m not talking about the projections,” Madden said. “I’m talking about the budget that we have before us right now. If you think that we’re overspending, then I need you to state in a meeting where you think we’re overspending and where we need to dial it back.”

Discon acknowledged that he did not yet have specific cuts to identify, saying Thursday was only the second hearing and that three remained.

“You’ll get it within the next, I guess we have three meetings, so I still have time to put all that together,” Discon said.

He maintained that his concern stems partly from the five-year forecast and his belief that the General Fund will decline more quickly than projected.

“This year’s forecast is completely different than last year’s forecast, but four of the years are still in it that were there last year,” Discon said. “So I’m wondering why all of a sudden is this forecast looking so bright? Is it just because we’re adding a Trader Joe’s every year?”

Zuckerman then joined Madden in challenging Discon’s assertion.

“If I was gonna come to a budget hearing and claim that we’re overspending and the budget is overspent, and this budget is overspending, and that the forecast is inaccurate, I would certainly have some details with me to do it,” Zuckerman said.

Discon objected to the increasingly pointed criticism, saying Madden and Zuckerman were “coming after” him. He continued to push back.

“I still think that there’s some overspending in this thing,” Discon said. “We don’t have the time right now for me to go into that, but I’m putting together a list of what I think we should be doing, and that will come to the next meeting.”

The exchange echoed Discon’s position during last year’s budget process. Discon cast the lone vote against the FY2026 operating budget, but when the council considered specific spending reductions, those amendments were offered by District II Councilman Kevin Vogeltanz. Discon instead sought to postpone the final vote and have the administration return with proposed cuts, a motion that died for lack of a second.

Under Mandeville’s form of government, the mayor proposes the annual budget, but the City Council holds the legislative authority to amend and ultimately adopt it — leaving council members to decide which expenditures, if any, should be removed before passage.

District I Councilwoman Cynthia Strong-Thompson then moved to adjourn, bringing the increasingly acrimonious exchange to an end.

The council has three budget hearings remaining, with the next scheduled Wednesday.

Moving forward

Discon has now committed publicly to identify the spending he believes should be reduced.

At the same time, Zuckerman has made clear that he intends to continue asking a different question throughout the budget process — not simply whether Mandeville has enough money, but whether taxpayers are being asked to provide more than the city can reasonably use when tens of millions of dollars may accumulate in restricted accounts.

The council will continue its review during three additional FY2027 budget hearings this month, with the next scheduled for 6 p.m. Wednesday, Aug. 19.

-30-


© 2026 Mandeville Daily. All rights reserved. Republishing permitted with attribution and link to the original article.

"The Prestigious Catahoula Newshound Award. An award I made up, then gave it to myself… five times." — "Wild" Bill Kropog, Editor Emeritus
“The Prestigious Catahoula Newshound Award. An award I made up, then gave it to myself… five times.” — “Wild” Bill Kropog, Editor Emeritus

FY2027 budget hearings open with first structurally balanced operating budget in years

Opening discussion reveals audit delay tied to city effort to correct fixed-asset records dating to the 1960s

Recurring revenues exceed recurring expenses by about $200,000

General Fund reserves remain above city’s newly adopted targets

MANDEVILLE — Mandeville’s proposed FY2027 budget would pay for recurring city operations entirely with recurring revenues for the first time in years, Finance Director Jessica Farno confirmed Wednesday during the first of five City Council budget hearings.

After removing grants, capital projects and other one-time revenues and expenditures, the proposed budget projects approximately $23.8 million in recurring revenues and transfers, with revenues exceeding recurring expenditures by about $200,000, a first in “many years.”

Councilman-at-Large Jason Zuckerman asked Farno to establish the distinction early in the council’s review of the budget.

“What I’m trying to get at … in this year’s proposed budget, are we covering our recurring expenditures with our recurring revenues?” Zuckerman asked.

“Yes,” Farno replied.

Zuckerman later noted that during his six budget cycles on the council, he had repeatedly heard that Mandeville was not covering recurring expenses entirely with recurring revenues.

“This is the first year in many years that we … are paying for recurring expenses with recurring revenue,” Zuckerman said.

“Correct,” Farno replied.

The approximately $200,000 margin is narrow. District I Councilwomen Cynthia Strong-Thompson and District III Councilwoman Jill Lane described it as providing little room for unexpected operating costs, with Strong-Thompson calling the structurally balanced proposal a “squeaker.”

But the recurring operating balance represents only one measure of the city’s overall financial position.

When grants, capital activity and other nonrecurring items are included, Farno said the FY2027 budget projects a net General Fund increase of approximately $8.7 million, although much of that amount results from the timing of multi-year capital appropriations and reimbursements rather than ordinary operating income.

Farno’s five-year projection also estimates an FY2027 ending General Fund balance of approximately $10.26 million, above the upper end of the 30% to 40% reserve target recently adopted by the council.

Even under the more conservative governmental fund calculation, which assumes outstanding capital appropriations remain committed, the city projects approximately $6.44 million in unappropriated General Fund balance — still above the 20% minimum reserve established by ordinance.

Audit discussion opens hearing

The council did not initially begin Wednesday’s hearing with those budget figures.

Councilman-at-Large Scott Discon instead opened the first FY2027 budget hearing by reading a prepared statement focused on the city’s delayed FY2025 audit, despite acknowledging in the statement that the unfinished audit does not prevent the council from legally proceeding with the budget process.

Discon’s emphasis on the delayed audit also echoed broader questions about the Madden administration’s financial management — including concerns over late audits — raised in recent anonymous mailers and websites targeting the mayor, although his statement did not reference the campaign.

Discon said a completed audit would provide a “certified look at our past financial health” and that future spending estimates are most effective when based upon “verified historical baselines.”

He said he had met with the city’s auditors the previous day and had been told the audit would be completed and submitted within approximately two weeks.

Discon said it was his “professional expectation” that the “official certified audit” be delivered before the council takes its final vote on the FY2027 budget later this month.

The discussion that followed, however, established that council members had already received repeated explanations of both the reason for the delay and the relationship between the unfinished audit and the FY2027 budget, possibly by email or other internal communications.

Zuckerman specifically asked that those explanations be placed on the public record rather than allowing the discussion to end with the fact that the audit had not yet been issued.

“I know there’s been a lot of correspondence [by email] and a lot of information that our director of finance has provided regarding that,” Zuckerman said. “I think that it was worthwhile rather than just throwing out there that … we don’t have the audit yet.”

Zuckerman said the public deserved to understand why the audit had been delayed and asked Farno and Mayor Clay Madden to explain what remained unfinished.

Madden also referenced the previous communications, saying council members had been kept informed about the audit and had received explanations through email, individual discussions and previous public comments.

The delay, officials explained, stems from a reconstruction of the city’s historical fixed-asset records after the current auditing firm identified deficiencies in beginning asset balances that had carried through previous audits.

The work has required researching city property and other assets dating back decades, including records from the 1960s.

Madden said auditors presented the city with the option of completing the audit earlier with the fixed-asset problem noted or delaying it while the underlying records were corrected.

“I said, ‘Let’s do this thing right,’” Madden said.

The problem predates both Madden’s administration and his previous service on the City Council, he said.

Farno then explained why the outstanding work does not undermine the figures being used in the FY2027 budget.

Fixed assets appear in the city’s government-wide financial statements, while the annual governmental budget is prepared at the fund level using revenues, expenditures and fund balances.

“The fund financial statements are essentially complete,” Farno said.

The draft audit remains the property of the auditors and is not yet a public document, she said, but those fund-level figures are substantially complete and agree with the figures she used to construct the proposed FY2027 budget.

“There’s really no support for the suggestion that the numbers that were used to develop this budget are inaccurate,” Farno said.

Zuckerman said the explanation was consistent with information he had received directly from the city’s auditors.

“After thorough discussions with the auditors myself, I feel very confident in the figures that Ms. Farno’s been working off of, and I have no issue whatsoever moving forward with the budget process this year,” he said.

District II Councilman Kevin Vogeltanz similarly said that while future audits should be completed on time, the outstanding fixed-asset work does not prevent the council from evaluating the FY2027 budget.

Farno also clarified that Discon’s stated expectation of receiving an “official certified audit” before the budget vote is unlikely to occur on that timetable. The auditors expect to submit the audit by the end of August, after which the Louisiana Legislative Auditor must review it before certification.

Lane asked directly whether that certification would occur before the council is expected to vote on the budget.

Farno said it would not.

Water and sewer presents different picture

While the proposed General Fund is structurally balanced and maintains substantial reserves, Wednesday’s review identified a considerably different financial problem in the city’s water and sewer enterprise fund.

The projected loss comes as the city is already preparing for an independent review of its water and sewer billing system following months of controversy over the rate structure adopted last year. In July, the council unanimously authorized the administration to seek a new consultant to review the current methodology and recommend changes aimed at balancing customer fairness with the requirement that the utility enterprise fund be financially self-sustaining. The review is also expected to examine alternative billing methods and whether the city should continue handling utility billing in-house.

The FY2027 proposal projects an approximately $2.44 million operating loss for the combined utility operation.

Zuckerman noted that last year’s budget projected an approximately $2 million operating loss, meaning the projected deficit has actually increased despite implementation of new water and sewer rates.

Farno confirmed that assessment.

The discussion also showed that the enterprise fund has depended on loans from the city’s other funds to maintain sufficient liquidity to pay its bills.

Draft FY2025 figures discussed Wednesday show approximately $7.7 million in enterprise-fund cash and investments while the fund owes approximately $8.6 million to other city funds.

“The only reason that it’s been able to support this is because of the liquidity in the other funds,” Farno said, adding that without those inter-fund loans, “we wouldn’t have been paying bills.”

That means eventually reaching operational break-even would stop the enterprise fund from accumulating additional losses but would not address the millions of dollars already owed to other city funds.

Farno also noted that money loaned to the enterprise fund could otherwise be invested by those funds and generating interest revenue.

The council previously authorized an outside review of the city’s water and sewer rate structure.

Other issues ahead

Sales-tax collections are currently running approximately 5% above the FY2026 budget, Farno said, while the FY2027 proposal assumes approximately 3.25% additional growth.

The administration’s proposed budget includes a 1% cost-of-living adjustment for employees in addition to budgeted merit increases. Council members requested calculations showing the full cost of the COLA and the effect that increasing it would have on the approximately $200,000 recurring operating surplus.

Farno said she and Madden had already modeled larger increases while constructing the budget.

“It didn’t work,” she said.

Zuckerman also requested a five-year projection of the city’s restricted funds, saying it will become increasingly important to understand the relationship between growing restricted balances and General Fund expenses as major city sales taxes approach renewal during the next five years.

The council will continue its review during four additional FY2027 budget hearings this month, with the next scheduled for 5 p.m. Aug. 13, one hour before the council’s regular meeting.

-30-


© 2026 Mandeville Daily. All rights reserved. Republishing permitted with attribution and link to the original article.

"The Prestigious Catahoula Newshound Award. An award I made up, then gave it to myself… five times." — "Wild" Bill Kropog, Editor Emeritus
“The Prestigious Catahoula Newshound Award. An award I made up, then gave it to myself… five times.” — “Wild” Bill Kropog, Editor Emeritus

Anonymous mailers, websites mount coordinated campaign against Madden administration

Three unsigned mailers and two anonymous websites share overlapping themes and technical similarities, potentially same or coordinated sources.

Campaign frequently portrays City Council actions as decisions made solely by the mayor.

2014 sales tax rededication played major role in $23M ‘surplus.’

MANDEVILLE — With Mandeville’s next municipal election still nearly two years away, three anonymous political mailers and two anonymously operated websites have mounted a sustained campaign criticizing Mayor Clay Madden’s administration on issues ranging from city finances to water and sewer rates.

The campaign frequently portrays Mayor Clay Madden as solely responsible for decisions that were, in fact, debated and approved by the City Council.

While the identities of those responsible remain unknown, Mandeville Daily found the websites share numerous technical and design characteristics with one another, that one closely mirrors the messaging found in the mailers, and that many of the campaign’s claims omit significant legislative and financial context.

Anonymous attacks, real impact graphic.(Mandeville Daily)
Anonymous attacks, real impact graphic.(Mandeville Daily)

Anonymous mailers target Madden administration with sensationalized claims

Rather than focusing on a single issue, the anonymous mailers collectively present a sustained political narrative about Mayor Clay Madden’s administration. Over the past several months, residents have received a series of professionally produced mailers criticizing the mayor’s handling of city finances, annual audits and water and sewer rates. While each mailing centers on a different topic, they follow a similar pattern: begin with a real event, public document or government statistic, then expand that fact into broader conclusions about Madden’s leadership while assigning responsibility almost exclusively to him.

One side of an attack bulk-mailer targeting Mayor Clay Madden sent to residents of Mandeville by an anonymous source. (Mandeville Daily)
One side of an attack bulk-mailer targeting Mayor Clay Madden sent to residents of Mandeville by an anonymous source. (Mandeville Daily)

That approach oversimplifies how municipal government actually functions. Under Louisiana law and Mandeville’s charter, many of the decisions highlighted in the mailers were not actions the mayor could take unilaterally. Annual budgets are adopted by ordinance or resolution of the City Council. Water and sewer rates are established by council ordinance. Financial reserve policies are enacted by council legislation. Long-range financial forecasts are planning documents prepared for elected officials to consider, not executive orders issued by the mayor. Whether one agrees or disagrees with those policies, they were ultimately adopted through votes of the City Council rather than by mayoral decree.

The mailers also largely ignore the legislative process behind those decisions. Many of the financial policies criticized were debated publicly during council meetings before being approved by council vote. In several instances, the actions cited in the mailers received unanimous or overwhelming support from council members. Presenting those decisions solely as actions of the mayor leaves readers without the broader governmental context in which they were made.

One side of an attack bulk-mailer targeting Mayor Clay Madden sent to residents of Mandeville by an anonymous source. (Mandeville Daily)
One side of an attack bulk-mailer targeting Mayor Clay Madden sent to residents of Mandeville by an anonymous source. (Mandeville Daily)

Some of the mailers likewise rely on long-range projections or isolated examples without acknowledging subsequent developments. For example, criticism of projected General Fund deficits does not mention that Mayor Clay Madden has since introduced a structurally balanced proposed FY2027 budget, which is currently under review by the City Council and may be amended before its anticipated adoption later this month. Nor do the mailers acknowledge that the City Council recently adopted a formal financial policy establishing a minimum unrestricted General Fund balance along with a target reserve range of 30% to 40% of annual operating expenditures.

That target substantially exceeds the Government Finance Officers Association’s widely recognized best-practice recommendation that general-purpose governments maintain unrestricted fund balances of at least two months of regular operating revenues or expenditures, or roughly 16.7%. Likewise, issues surrounding the city’s utility-rate structure have not been left unaddressed. The City Council has already authorized an independent review of the water and sewer rate methodology, signaling that elected officials are continuing to evaluate the system rather than treating it as settled policy.

Historical General Fund balances show Mandeville’s audited year-end reserve from FY2010 through FY2024. The chart also identifies several significant events—including the 2014 sales tax rededication, the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic, Mayor Clay Madden’s election and Hurricane Ida—for historical context. The event markers do not imply a causal relationship. (Mandeville Daily)
Historical General Fund balances show Mandeville’s audited year-end reserve from FY2010 through FY2024. The chart also identifies several significant events—including the 2014 sales tax rededication, the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic, Mayor Clay Madden’s election and Hurricane Ida—for historical context. The event markers do not imply a causal relationship. (Mandeville Daily)

[View Full-Size Chart ↗]

As for the oft-cited $23 million General Fund balance, the Madden administration and several members of the City Council have offered a markedly different interpretation. They contend the reserve grew substantially after voters approved a 2014 reallocation of one-half cent of the city’s existing one-cent sales tax from infrastructure funds to the General Fund, creating a recurring revenue stream of approximately $2.3 million annually at the time, with collections increasing in subsequent years as taxable sales grew.

According to that view, the resulting revenue shift — not necessarily annual operating surpluses — accounted for a significant portion of the balance over the following decade. They further argue that major infrastructure maintenance and expansion projects often failed to move forward amid repeated disagreements between the former mayor and successive City Councils over proposed spending, while employee compensation remained largely stagnant during the previous administration’s 12-year tenure. Those circumstances, they contend, produced both a sizable General Fund balance and a backlog of infrastructure needs, and explain why a portion of the reserve has since been intentionally used to address deferred capital projects and long-delayed employee compensation rather than being depleted through unplanned spending.

The mailers overstate the city’s audit history. Although Mandeville did submit annual audits after statutory deadlines during Madden’s administration, the claim that the city has been delinquent on every annual financial audit since he became mayor is not supported by the public record.

The handful of unusually high water bills that generated headlines — and were later featured prominently in the anonymous mailer and website — also proved to be extreme outliers rather than evidence of a widespread billing spike. Only a small number of residents appeared at council meetings with the most dramatic increases, which occurred during an unusually long, roughly six-week transition billing period. Subsequent review found the meters were functioning properly and that the water reflected on the bills had actually been consumed. While the new rate structure intentionally shifted more of the cost to high-volume users, city officials reported that most customers saw relatively little change or even decreases in their bills. The council has since hired an independent consultant to reassess the rate structure itself. Meanwhile, city officials said the unusually high bills that drew the initial publicity returned to expected levels during subsequent billing cycles, leaving the cases highlighted in news reports and the anonymous campaign as notable but unrepresentative extremes.

None of this necessarily means every criticism contained in the mailers is without merit. Questions about audit timeliness, long-term financial planning and utility-rate policy are legitimate subjects of public debate. The issue is not whether citizens should criticize their local government; it is whether those criticisms fairly portray how municipal decisions are actually made and who is legally responsible for them.

Anonymous websites reveal common technical fingerprints, overlapping content

The mailers are not the only anonymous political material targeting Madden. Two websites — FireClayMadden.com and MandevilleWatergate.com — also criticize the administration without readily identifying who created or operates them. A review of the sites found numerous similarities and direct connections between them, including the same WordPress Pro/Cornerstone framework, related design elements and imagery, and links from Fire Clay Madden to Mandeville Watergate content.

Comparison of graphics used in two anonymous attack websites targeting Mayor Clay Madden. (Mandeville Daily)
Comparison of graphics used in two anonymous attack websites targeting Mayor Clay Madden. (Mandeville Daily)

Neither site identifies its designer or operator, and both appear to have been assembled from commercially available WordPress tools rather than through a professional custom-built web platform.

The similarities extend beyond the software used to build them. Both sites use closely related graphics of Madden, including versions of the same photograph of him giving a thumbs-up, while Fire Clay Madden incorporates the water-bill controversy prominently into its broader criticism of the mayor. Technical checks also found the two domains hosted on consecutive IP addresses within the same hosting environment. None of those details alone establishes common ownership, but taken together they indicate the sites are closely related.

The connection is notable in examining the anonymous mail campaign because at least one of the mailers substantially mirrors themes and content appearing on one of the websites. There is no evidence presently establishing who produced the three mailers or who operates the two websites, nor that the same person or organization is responsible for all five. However, the overlapping content and the connections between the two websites raise the question of whether the anonymous political materials are part of a coordinated effort rather than unrelated campaigns.

-30-


© 2026 Mandeville Daily. All rights reserved. Republishing permitted with attribution and link to the original article.

"The Prestigious Catahoula Newshound Award. An award I made up, then gave it to myself… five times." — "Wild" Bill Kropog, Editor Emeritus
“The Prestigious Catahoula Newshound Award. An award I made up, then gave it to myself… five times.” — “Wild” Bill Kropog, Editor Emeritus

LSU Health Foundation, Woodward Harbor seek to revive dismissed Sucette Harbor appeal

Plaintiffs cite attorney oversight in bid to reopen Fifth Circuit appeal

UPDATE: Appeal reinstated by court


Update (Aug. 7): The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit has granted LSU Health Foundation New Orleans and Woodward Harbor’s motion to reinstate the appeal, restoring the case to the court’s active docket. The appeal had been dismissed three days earlier after the appellants failed to timely file required record excerpts. Attorneys for the plaintiffs acknowledged the omission in a subsequent motion, describing it as “an isolated oversight based on internal miscommunications.” The Fifth Circuit granted the request without further explanation, allowing the appeal of U.S. District Judge Brandon S. Long’s dismissal to proceed.


MANDEVILLE — Just one day after the U.S. Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals dismissed their appeal for failure to prosecute, LSU Health Foundation New Orleans and Woodward Harbor LLC have asked the court to reinstate the case, acknowledging the dismissal resulted from an internal oversight by their attorneys.

In a motion filed Wednesday, the plaintiffs ask the appellate court to reopen the appeal after it was dismissed Aug. 4 because required record excerpts were not timely filed. Their attorneys state the omission was “an isolated oversight based on internal miscommunications” and argue the deficiency has now been corrected by filing the required documents.

The motion notes that the plaintiffs had timely filed their principal appellate brief on July 10 and contends reopening the appeal would not prejudice the City of Mandeville because the city has already received an unopposed extension until Sept. 9 to file its response brief.

Attorneys for LSU Health Foundation and Woodward Harbor attribute the missed appellate filing deadline to “an isolated oversight based on internal miscommunications” in a motion asking the Fifth Circuit to reopen the appeal. (Mandeville Daily)
Attorneys for LSU Health Foundation and Woodward Harbor attribute the missed appellate filing deadline to “an isolated oversight based on internal miscommunications” in a motion asking the Fifth Circuit to reopen the appeal. (Mandeville Daily)

To satisfy the Fifth Circuit’s reinstatement procedures, the plaintiffs attached the missing record excerpts, including the district court docket, notice of appeal, final judgment and the orders entered by U.S. District Judge Brandon S. Long dismissing the claims at issue.

The motion also states that counsel for the City of Mandeville was contacted on Aug. 4 and again on Aug. 5 regarding the request but had not indicated whether the city would oppose reinstatement of the appeal.

The appeal seeks review of Judge Long’s February ruling dismissing with prejudice the remaining claims brought by LSU Health Foundation and Woodward Harbor against the City of Mandeville. As before, the appeal does not include claims against Councilman-at-Large Jason Zuckerman, whose dismissal is not being challenged.

If granted, the motion would simply restore the appeal to the court’s active docket. The Fifth Circuit has not yet ruled on whether it will reinstate the case.

-30-


© 2026 Mandeville Daily. All rights reserved. Republishing permitted with attribution and link to the original article.

Federal appeals court dismisses LSU Health Foundation appeal against Mandeville

Fifth Circuit court throws out appeal in latest setback for Sucette Harbor plaintiffs


UPDATE: LSU Health Foundation, Woodward Harbor seek to revive dismissed Sucette Harbor appeal


MANDEVILLE — A federal appeals court has dismissed LSU Health Foundation New Orleans’ appeal challenging the dismissal of its lawsuit against the City of Mandeville, leaving the lower court’s ruling in favor of the city in place unless the appeal is later reinstated.

LSU Health Foundation had already abandoned their appeal of the dismissal of their claims against Zuckerman individually.

The dismissal, issued Tuesday by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit, was not based on the merits of the case. Instead, the court dismissed the appeal “for want of prosecution” after finding the appellants failed to timely file required record excerpts.

The underlying federal lawsuit stems from the long-running legal battle surrounding the proposed Sucette Harbor development, in which LSU Health Foundation New Orleans and Woodward Harbor, LLC, sued the City of Mandeville and Zuckerman after the city rejected a development proposal for the lakefront property.

An excerpt from the dismissal dated August 4, 2026. (Mandeville Daily)
An excerpt from the dismissal dated August 4, 2026. (Mandeville Daily)

The Fifth Circuit’s order states that the appeal was dismissed under Rule 42.3 after the appellants failed to comply with appellate filing requirements.

The dismissal leaves intact U.S. District Judge Brandon S. Long’s decision dismissing the claims against the City and Zuckerman, representing another significant procedural victory for the defendants in a series of lawsuits arising from the failed development proposal.

Although the appeal has been dismissed, the Fifth Circuit’s rules allow certain appeals dismissed for want of prosecution to be reinstated under limited circumstances if the appellant corrects the procedural deficiency and successfully petitions the court for reinstatement.

The latest ruling comes as related litigation continues in federal court. The City of Mandeville and Zuckerman are pursuing claims seeking recovery of attorney’s fees and sanctions against LSU Health Foundation and its former attorneys following the dismissal of the underlying lawsuit.

The appeal was being handled by different counsel than the attorneys who originally represented LSU Health Foundation in the litigation. The foundation retained new appellate counsel after its previous legal team withdrew from the case following widely publicized sanctions proceedings involving court filings that included nonexistent legal citations generated by artificial intelligence.

The Fifth Circuit’s dismissal issued Tuesday was based on a separate procedural issue, stating that the appellants failed to timely file required record excerpts.

If the appeal is not reinstated, the district court’s judgment in favor of the City and Zuckerman will remain the final disposition of that portion of the federal litigation.

-30-


© 2026 Mandeville Daily. All rights reserved. Republishing permitted with attribution and link to the original article.