Proposed resolution would allow comments on ordinance introductions, increase speaking time and largely preserve the council’s existing meeting procedures
Discon-sponsored resolution would reverse his ruling on public comments from 2 weeks earlier
MANDEVILLE — The City Council is scheduled Thursday to consider replacing its current rules of procedure with a new resolution that would reverse a controversial interpretation of the council’s public comment rules adopted just two weeks ago.
Resolution 26-32, sponsored by Councilman-at-Large Scott Discon, would repeal and replace Resolution 24-44, the rules governing City Council meetings adopted in 2024. While most of the proposal simply carries forward the council’s existing procedures, it would expressly allow residents to discuss ordinance introductions during the general public comment period, reversing a Discon interpretation the council backed by a 3-2 vote at its July 9 meeting. The proposal also increases public comment time from three minutes to four minutes and formally incorporates the council’s current practice of holding general public comment at the beginning of meetings.

The change follows a dispute during the council’s July 9 meeting over whether residents could use the general public comment period to discuss an ordinance appearing on the agenda for introduction but not for debate or final action.
Before public comment began that evening, Discon, serving as council chairman, ruled that citizens could not comment on the proposed Monroe Street low-traffic overlay ordinance because it appeared on the meeting agenda under ordinance introductions.
Because ordinance introductions are not voted on, Louisiana law does not require a public hearing before they are presented. That makes the council’s general public comment period the only opportunity for citizens to publicly address an ordinance at the meeting where it is introduced.
District II Councilman Kevin Vogeltanz challenged that interpretation, arguing the rule had never been intended to prohibit discussion of ordinance introductions. Instead, he said the provision was intended only to prevent citizens from receiving additional speaking time by commenting both during an item’s required public hearing and again during the general public comment period.
The council ultimately voted 3-2 to uphold the chair’s ruling. Only Vogeltanz and Councilman-at-Large Jason Zuckerman voted to overrule Discon’s interpretation.
The proposed resolution now changes the language at the center of that dispute.
Under Resolution 24-44, residents could use the general public comment period to speak on “any non-agenda item.” Resolution 26-32 instead provides that, time permitting, members of the public may speak “on any non-agenda item, or Ordinance introduction.”
The revised wording appears to supersede the interpretation adopted July 9 by expressly identifying ordinance introductions as a permissible topic during general public comment. Notably, the proposal to make that change was sponsored by Discon, the same council chairman whose earlier ruling would effectively be replaced if the resolution is adopted.
Aside from the public comment revisions, the proposal would make relatively few substantive changes to the council’s procedures.
The resolution increases the standard speaking time from three minutes to four minutes for both general public comment and comments made before votes on agenda items.
It also formally incorporates the council’s current practice of holding general public comment near the beginning of meetings. Although Resolution 24-44 contemplated general public comment later in the meeting, the council has been following the revised order in practice for some time.
Otherwise, the proposal leaves the council’s procedural framework largely intact. Robert’s Rules of Order would remain the governing parliamentary authority, the council chair would continue to set meeting agendas, written public comment procedures would remain unchanged, and existing provisions governing meeting decorum, disruptive conduct and annual election of the council chair would all remain in place.
If adopted, Resolution 26-32 would repeal Resolution 24-44 in its entirety and become the governing rules of procedure for future Mandeville City Council meetings.
-30-
© 2026 Mandeville Daily. All rights reserved. Republishing permitted with attribution and link to the original article.


2 thoughts on “Council to consider reversing public comment interpretation in proposed rules rewrite”